Abstract:We propose a synthesis of the two proof styles of interactive theorem proving: the procedural style (where proofs are scripts of commands, like in Coq) and the declarative style (where proofs are texts in a controlled natural language, like in Isabelle/Isar). Our approach combines the advantages of the declarative style - the possibility to write formal proofs like normal mathematical text - and the procedural style - strong automation and help with shaping the proofs, including determining the statements of intermediate steps. Our approach is new, and differs significantly from the ways in which the procedural and declarative proof styles have been combined before in the Isabelle, Ssreflect and Matita systems. Our approach is generic and can be implemented on top of any procedural interactive theorem prover, regardless of its architecture and logical foundations. To show the viability of our proposed approach, we fully implemented it as a proof interface called miz3, on top of the HOL Light interactive theorem prover. The declarative language that this interface uses is a slight variant of the language of the Mizar system, and can be used for any interactive theorem prover regardless of its logical foundations. The miz3 interface allows easy access to the full set of tactics and formal libraries of HOL Light, and as such has "industrial strength". Our approach gives a way to automatically convert any procedural proof to a declarative counterpart, where the converted proof is similar in size to the original. As all declarative systems have essentially the same proof language, this gives a straightforward way to port proofs between interactive theorem provers.

Mizar: State-of-the-art and Beyond

The Role of the Mizar Mathematical Library for Interactive Proof Development in Mizar

New developments in parsing Mizar

MizAR 40 for Mizar 40

A Wiki for Mizar: Motivation, Considerations, and Initial Prototype

Extracting Higher-Order Goals from the Mizar Mathematical Library

Sentence complexity of theorems in Mizar

An Integrated Web Platform for the Mizar Mathematical Library

Documentation Generator Focusing on Symbols for the HTML-ized Mizar Library

A Synthesis of the Procedural and Declarative Styles of Interactive Theorem Proving

Automating Boolean Set Operations in Mizar Proof Checking with the Aid of an External SAT Solver

Hammering Mizar by Learning Clause Guidance

Remote Verification System for Mizar Integrated with Emwiki

Number Theory and Axiomatic Geometry in the Diproche System

Solving Hard Mizar Problems with Instantiation and Strategy Invention

A scalable module system

Abstract Modular Systems and Solvers

Towards Semantic Markup of Mathematical Documents via User Interaction

Wikimirs 3.0: A Hybrid Mir System Based On The Context, Structure And Importance Of Formulae In A Document

Interaction with Formal Mathematical Documents in Isabelle/PIDE

GeoLogic -- Graphical interactive theorem prover for Euclidean geometry