Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to address the main arguments put forward in Grietjie Verhoef’s article and contribute to a wider debate among management scholars on the role of indigenous theories. It challenges the view of African management as illusory and points to the rising support for indigenous theories as indicative of the weakening of the unquestioned dominance of universal theories. Design/methodology/approach This paper takes a conceptual and critically reflective approach, underpinned by a 360-degree evaluation of pertinent literature and theoretical arguments. Findings This paper reveals an underlying symmetry and interconnectedness, anchored on a shared communal ethos, among Afrocentric management concepts, specifically Ubuntu, Ekpe and Igbo apprenticeship systems. This symmetry points to an underlying indigenous management theory that begs to be further conceptualised, evidenced and advanced. Research limitations/implications This paper affirms Verhoef’s demand for Ubuntu, Ekpe, Igbo apprenticeship system to be more rigorously developed and theoretically coherent and urges scholars to intensify effort towards advancing the conceptual and empirical foundations of African management. Echoing Mahatma Gandhi’s timeless counsel, this paper calls on critics of African management to join the effort to bring about the change they wish to see in African management theorising. Social implications This paper disavows the alleged effort to impose a single “African management” model or perpetuate the “colonial/indigenous” binary divide but equally cautions against an effort to veto scholarly striving for a common identity, to learn from history or not embrace collective amnesia. As examples from the USA and Europe show, diversity, even heterogeneity, needs not to preclude the forging of a commonly shared identity complemented with appropriate sub-identities. Originality/value This paper links the African management-centred themes addressed by Verhoef to the wider debate among management scholars about lessening the dominance of universal theories and allowing space for context-resonant indigenous theories. It calls on African management scholars to invest the premium and intensified effort towards building a more robust and coherent body of indigenous theory that will have the capacity and efficacy to inform, explain and advance organisational practice and outcomes across Africa.

Towards advancing African management scholarship

Still the Dark Continent? Towards contextual methodological approaches to management development research in foreign multinational firms in Africa

Management Theory, Research and Practice for Sustainable Development in Africa: A Commentary from a Practitioner's Perspective

Postcolonialism, Organization, and Management Theory

Two Decades of International Business and International Management Scholarship on Africa: A Review and Future Directions

The dynamics of managing people in the diverse cultural and institutional context of Africa

Towards a relevant African philosophy of education

Sustainability and global value chains in Africa: Introduction to the Special Issue

Understanding Ubuntu and its contribution to social work education in Africa and other regions of the world

Educational leadership, management and administration in Africa: an analysis of contemporary literature

Contributions of African Traditional Knowledge to Community Development Theory and Practice

Management Accounting Research on Africa

Is indigenisation a social justice risk? Exploring indigenisation of social work in Africa through the lens of universalism versus relativism of social work ethics and values

Towards an African education research methodology: decolonising new knowledge

Decolonising research in a Sub-Saharan African context: exploring Ubuntu as a foundation for research methodology, ethics and agenda

Management and Building Theory: the Strategies of Research on Chinese Native Management

African Ubuntu and Sustainable Development Goals: seeking human mutual relations and service in development

Teaching Ancient Egyptian Philosophy of Education in Teacher Education

“Decolonisation” and “Africanisation” of Knowledge: Politico-Ideological or Educational Concepts?

Rigor and Relevance in Asian Management Research: Where Are We and Where Can We Go?

Identity and culture in theorising African perspectives of communication: The case of an African cinematic model