Abstract:In this study, an expert knowledge-based model, a logistic regression model, and an artificial neural network model were compared for their accuracy and portability in landslide susceptibility mapping. Two study areas (the Kaixian and the Three Gorges areas in China) were selected for this comparison based on their well-known, high landslide hazard. To evaluate the performance of these models and to minimize the impact of the particularity of a study area on model performance, cross-applications of three models between the two study areas were conducted. When the Kaixian area was used as a model development area, prediction accuracy for the expert knowledge-based model, the logistic regression model, and the artificial neural network model were 71.5%, 81.0% and 100.0%, respectively. The high prediction accuracy of the two data-driven models were expected because the observed landslide occurrence used in training the models were also used to validate their respective performance, while the expert knowledge-based model did not use these observations for training. The perfect accuracy for the neural network model can also be attributed to its over-prediction of the susceptibility. When breaking the susceptibility into four classes: very low susceptibility (0–0.25), low susceptibility (0.25–0.5), high susceptibility (0.5–0.75), and very high susceptibility (0.75–1), the observed landslide density at the very high susceptibility level is 0.303/km2, 0.212/km2, and 0.195/km2 for the expert knowledge-based model, the logistic regression model, and the artificial neural network model, respectively. This suggests that the expert knowledge-based model was much better than the other two data-driven models at evaluating landslide occurrence in very high susceptibility areas. When the three models developed in the Kaixian area were applied in the Three Gorges area without any changes, their prediction accuracy dropped to 44.8% for the logistic regression model and 81.6% for the artificial neural network model, while the expert knowledge-based model maintained its initial accuracy level of 82.8%. The landslide density for the very high susceptibility areas in the Three Georges area was 0.275/km2, 0.082/km2, and 0.060/km2 for the expert knowledge-based model, the logistic model, and the artificial neural network model, respectively. These results indicate that the expert knowledge-based model is more effective at predicting areas with very high susceptibility. When the Three Gorges area was used as a model development area and the Kaixian area was used as the model application area, similar results were obtained. Results from the two experiments show that the performance of the logistic regression model and artificial neural network model is not as stable as the expert knowledge-based model when transferred to a new area. This suggests that the expert knowledge-based model is more suitable for landslide susceptibility mapping over large areas.

Spatial Prediction of Landslide Hazard at the Yihuang Area (China): A Comparative Study on the Predictive Ability of Backpropagation Multi-layer Perceptron Neural Networks and Radial Basic Function Neural Networks

GIS-based Comparative Study of Bayes Network, Hoeffding Tree and Logistic Model Tree for Landslide Susceptibility Modeling

GIS-based Soil Planar Slide Susceptibility Mapping Using Logistic Regression and Neural Networks: a Typical Red Mudstone Area in Southwest China

Performance Evaluation of the GIS-based Data Mining Techniques of Best-First Decision Tree, Random Forest, and Naïve Bayes Tree for Landslide Susceptibility Modeling

A novel hybrid artificial intelligence approach based on the rotation forest ensemble and naïve Bayes tree classifiers for a landslide susceptibility assessment in Langao County, China

Landslide Susceptibility Modeling Based on GIS and Novel Bagging-Based Kernel Logistic Regression

Landslide Susceptibility Evaluating Using Artificial Intelligence Method in the Youfang District (China)

GIS-Based Comparative Study of the Bayesian Network, Decision Table, Radial Basis Function Network and Stochastic Gradient Descent for the Spatial Prediction of Landslide Susceptibility

A comparative study of different neural network models for landslide susceptibility mapping

Introducing a novel multi-layer perceptron network based on stochastic gradient descent optimized by a meta-heuristic algorithm for landslide susceptibility mapping

Shallow Landslide Susceptibility Models Based on Artificial Neural Networks Considering the Factor Selection Method and Various Non-Linear Activation Functions

Landslide susceptibility assessment using the certainty factor and deep neural network

Evaluation of neural network models for landslide susceptibility assessment

Application of artificial neural networks and geographic information system to provide hazard susceptibility maps for rockfall failures

Landslide Occurrence Prediction Using Trainable Cascade Forward Network and Multilayer Perceptron

Spatial Prediction of Landslide Susceptibility Using Logistic Regression (LR), Functional Trees (FTs), and Random Subspace Functional Trees (RSFTs) for Pengyang County, China

A Comparative Study of an Expert Knowledge-Based Model and Two Data-Driven Models for Landslide Susceptibility Mapping

Landslide Susceptibility Mapping Based on Deep Learning Algorithms Using Information Value Analysis Optimization

Application of artificial neural network in landslide susceptibility assessment

Landslide susceptibility prediction based on a semi-supervised multiple-layer perceptron model

Application of Back Propagation Neural Networks with Optimization of Genetic Algorithms to Landslide Hazard Prediction