Abstract:An exploration of the value attached to the work experience of graduates, and particularly the value of part-time working whilst studying for a degree, from an employer's perspective, is reported. A documentary analysis of graduate recruiters was conducted to assess the extent to which work experience was specified for graduate employment programmes. Further interviews were then carried out with a sample of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) to explore how the part-time working of graduates is perceived by employers. Work experience is deemed to be important to employers, not only as a differentiator but also as a measure of how graduates will perform in-post. Employers generally signalled the value of work experience, but indicated that graduates did not make best use of it in their job applications. It is argued that the findings will provide information to universities and educators about the contribution and importance of students' part-time working in terms of graduate employment prospects and with respect to the employability agenda in the HE curriculum in the UK.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to explore the value of work experience for graduates, particularly the impact of part-time work on graduate employment, analyzed from the employer's perspective. Specifically, the study attempts to answer the following questions:
1. **To what extent do employers require work experience when hiring graduates?**
- The study evaluates the specific requirements for work experience by analyzing job postings on recruitment websites.
2. **To what extent can part-time work increase an individual's advantage when applying for graduate positions?**
- Through surveys and interviews, the study seeks to understand employers' views on part-time work experience and whether these experiences help graduates stand out in the job market.
3. **Which types of part-time work activities are considered more useful?**
- The study explores whether different types of part-time work (such as retail, service industry, etc.) are viewed as more valuable by employers.
4. **Does part-time work help graduates stand out in the job market?**
- The study analyzes whether part-time work experience can be an important factor in distinguishing candidates.
5. **How can students more effectively utilize part-time work experience to improve their employment prospects?**
- The study provides suggestions to help students better showcase the skills and experiences gained from part-time work to enhance their job competitiveness.
### Research Background
With the increasing focus of the UK government on graduate employability, universities are also striving to support students in transitioning smoothly into the workplace. However, the transition from higher education to the workplace is not straightforward. Although "employability" is often defined as the skills and attributes that make individuals attractive to employers, in practice, individuals also need to develop personal qualities to adapt to and enhance their careers. Therefore, the relationship between universities and employers becomes complex, especially regarding work experience. Many employers explicitly require graduates to possess specific skills, such as problem-solving and effective communication, and expect graduates to contribute immediately to the company. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) particularly need graduates who can quickly adapt and enhance business performance.
### Research Methods
1. **Literature Analysis**:
- By analyzing job postings on top employer websites published by The Times and Job Crowd, the study evaluates the importance of work experience in recruitment.
2. **Interviews**:
- Interviews were conducted with recruitment managers from 9 SMEs located in the West Midlands region of the UK to gain in-depth insights into their views on part-time work and its role in graduate job applications.
### Main Findings
1. **Literature Analysis Results**:
- 11.3% of employers explicitly require graduates to have work experience.
- 9.4% of employers consider work experience desirable.
- 20.2% of employers imply that work experience helps demonstrate skills or behaviors.
- 56.3% of employers do not explicitly require work experience but expect applicants to possess certain behaviors or qualities.
- 2.3% of employers explicitly state that work experience is not required.
- 0.5% of employers believe that too much work experience (e.g., more than 12 months) may be detrimental.
2. **Interview Results**:
- Employers generally believe that work experience helps distinguish similar candidates.
- Part-time work experience is considered to help students develop a broader range of skills and experiences, especially the ability to interact with customers.
- Employers do not particularly focus on where students gain part-time work experience, believing that any environment can provide opportunities to develop necessary skills.
- Some employers have a positive attitude towards management experience and charity work, while others believe these experiences may not significantly help the application.
- Employers criticize some graduates for failing to fully utilize their skills and work experience in their applications, suggesting that students better showcase these advantages.
### Conclusion
Work experience is very important to employers, not only as a tool to distinguish candidates but also as a basis for evaluating graduates' performance after joining the company. SMEs, in particular, prefer to hire graduates with practical work experience. Therefore, students should make full use of part-time work opportunities to accumulate relevant experience and effectively showcase these experiences when applying for jobs.