Shades of True Womanhood for Slave Women in Uncle Tom’s Cabin
S. E. Stewart
Abstract:Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin is a racially problematic novel, despite her goals to advocate for teaching Christianity to black people, eliminate slavery, and bring Christianity to Africa. In pursuing these goals, Stowe recreates a paternalistic whiteness modeled on paternalistic slavery. Critics have long accused Stowe of romantic racialism and using well-known minstrel show stock characters as the inspiration for the slave characters, but I argue that these problems are a natural result of Stowe’s goals for the novel. If black people can be seen as naturally subordinate to white people and reliant on white people for their Christian salvation, it can be said that they are not equipped for or suited to an equal place in American society, even if slavery is abolished. At the same time, because of white Christians’ duties, slavery cannot continue to exist. Given this conflict, emigrating and bringing Christianity to Africa becomes the only option for free black people. As a result of Stowe’s goals and her approach to them, sympathetic whites throughout the novel replace slave owners as representatives of the patriarchy without the sin of slavery. In order to explore the novel’s paternalistic whiteness, I will use white Christian womanhood as a lens to discuss the ways in which slave women are portrayed, perceived, and treated by Stowe. She uses white women as the standard for femininity and Christian womanhood, while slave women are split into two groups, based on the shades of their skin, each one fitting the description of a minstrel character. The minstrelsy serves as a distracting measure of intelligence and beauty, taking away the female slaves’ humanity, equality, and womanhood, and making them into characters rather than people. My argument offers a new
History,Sociology