The role of race in the stereotyping of a speaker ’ s accent as native or non-native
Deepa Bhuvanagiri,Anna Grahlherr,Pamela Beardsell,Jaishree Chittoor,Donald Rubin
2019-01-01
Abstract:Introduction Humans often form opinions about a person or a group based on certain characteristics or traits they possess. This ability to infer information about a person or group is an evolutionary response that is thought to have helped members from different tribes recognize friends from foes during encounters (1). As society has become more heterogeneous, this once adaptive advantage is now a social problem that affects people who are deemed different. Several factors such as race, gender, age, physical appearance, and non-physical characteristics such as religion, profession, and accent of the person determine membership into a group. Stereotypes emerge when a particular group becomes associated with preconceived ideas. An example of stereotyping is the idea that Asians are smart and socially awkward or that women are not good at math. Since demographic groups are not homogenous with respect to abilities and behaviors, making assumptions of individuals based on stereotypes can result in incorrect conclusions and has become a big problem in the modern world, especially because it can limit the advancement and opportunities of groups of people: women may be less likely to be hired for a job that requires training in math or engineering, or Asians may be perceived as too socially awkward for leadership positions. Social identity threat and stereotype threat are consequences of stereotyping that are experienced by members within and between groups. Social identity threat happens when a group faces a threat to their positive perception. Under such conditions, they reinforce the behaviors that align them to the group and justify their superiority over rival groups (2). Stereotype threat happens to individuals within a group that are associated with negative stereotypes. Members of the group, when made aware of their negative stereotypes, perform poorly. This was demonstrated by Steele and Aronson, 1995 (3) where they showed that African American students, when told about the achievement gap associated with their group, under preformed on standardized tests. Overall, the stereotyping of a group or community has been shown to result in burnouts (4), learning impediments (5), lower performance (6-8), and increase in discrimination between in groups and out groups (9). The perception of an accent is affected by stereotyping. In general, Caucasian Americans report less bias on the perception of their accents as nonnative than native born Asian Americans. The Caucasian Americans also report less bias on the perception of their nationality. That is, Caucasian Americans are less likely to be perceived as foreign compared with Asian Americans (10). So, an Asian-American is under constant pressure to prove themselves as Americans. This kind of stereotyping tested in this study is known as “Perpetual Foreigner” (11, 12). In America, the term Perpetual Foreigner refers to the concept of an Asian American being perceived by the majority group as the “other” and not a “true” American. Such stereotyping can lead Asian Americans to question their identity and their sense of belonging in American culture. The role of race in the stereotyping of a speaker’s accent as native or non-native