Cultural Difference in Conflict Management Strategies of Children and Its Development: Comparing 3- and 5-Year-olds Across China, Japan, and Korea.
Hiroki Maruyama,Tatsuo Ujiie,Jiro Takai,Yuko Takahama,Hiroko Sakagami,Makoto Shibayama,Mayumi Fukumoto,Katsumi Ninomiya,Park Hyang Ah,Xiaoxia Feng,Chie Takatsuji,Miwa Hirose,Rei Kudo,Yoshihiro Shima,Rumiko Nakayama,Noriko Hamaie,Feng Zhang,Satoshi Moriizumi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10409289.2015.1036344
2015-01-01
Early Education and Development
Abstract:Research Findings: The purpose of this study was to examine differences in the development of conflict management strategies, focusing on 3- and 5-year-olds, through a comparison of 3 neighboring Asian cultures, those of China (n=114), Japan (n=98), and Korea (n=90). The dual concern model of conflict management was adopted to probe which strategy children would prefer to use in 2 hypothetical conflict situations. Results indicated that, first, for disagreement, 3-year-olds in the 3 countries equally preferred the dominating strategy. For competition for resources, 3-year-olds differed in their strategy preference across all cultures. Second, the observed strategy preference of 3- to 5-year-old children in this study was more or less different from that of older schoolchildren, regardless of culture. Practice or Policy: These findings suggest the significance of the context, the complexity of the phenomenon of the development of cultural differences, and the significance of cohort sampling.