From monuments to megapixels: Death, memory, and symbolic immortality in the contemporary United States

Jeffrey Bennett,Jenny Huberman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1463499615575943
IF: 2.078
2015-09-01
Anthropological Theory
Abstract:This article explores transformations in the American way of death from the Victorian period to the present. It asks: What do recent shifts in mortuary practice and memorialization reveal about larger changes in American culture and society? And what is at stake in charting and understanding these changes for anthropologists interested in technology and culture change more generally? We argue that the move away from the lavish Victorian funeral to cheaper, less traditional ways of caring for the dead is productively conceptualized as a shift in differing memorial paradigms. In the case at hand, we characterize this paradigm shift as one from ‘monuments’ to ‘megapixels’, the former being ascendant at the beginning of the era of film photography and the latter becoming ascendant with the rise of social and digital media. We trace the development and central features of these two memorial paradigms, showing how the rise of film photography played a central role in facilitating the transition between them, and we explore how these memorial paradigms have provided Americans with alternative ways of combatting death anxiety since the 19th century. Ultimately, we argue that today’s virtual memorials and online cemeteries have arisen to provide a growing number of Americans with a sense of symbolic immortality that has become increasingly difficult to realize by more traditional means. However, we also consider how these new means of digital memorialization might be altering the memorial landscape in new ways and changing how the bereaved cope with object loss.
anthropology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the changes in American death culture from the Victorian era to the present, especially how the transformation of funeral customs and memorial methods reflects broader cultural and social changes. The authors raise two main questions: 1. **What greater changes in American culture and society are revealed by the recent changes in funeral customs and memorial methods?** 2. **What do these changes mean for anthropologists, especially in the study of technological and cultural change?** Specifically, the paper explores how these changes affect the way Americans cope with death anxiety by analyzing the memorial paradigm shift from "monuments" to "megapixels". The author believes that with the development of society and technology, traditional funeral and memorial methods have gradually been replaced by more modern and digital ones. This transformation has not only changed the way people remember the deceased, but also influenced their perception of death and coping strategies. ### Main Arguments: - **The Shift from "Monuments" to "Megapixels"**: Funerals in the Victorian era emphasized luxury and tradition, while contemporary ones tend to be cheaper and more non - traditional. This shift can be understood as a transition from material memorials (such as tombstones and mausoleums) to digital memorials (such as virtual memorial halls and online cemeteries). - **The Significance of Digital Memorials**: Modern technology, especially digital photography and personal websites, provides people with a new way to achieve symbolic immortality. These digital memorial methods not only provide a means of maintaining contact with the deceased, but also change people's understanding of life, death and memory. - **Cultural and Social Influences**: This transformation reflects the profound changes in American society against the background of industrialization, urbanization and technological progress, including changes in family structure, weakening of community relations and changes in the concept of time. ### Conclusion: The paper argues that although contemporary Americans may no longer attach as much importance to traditional funeral ceremonies as they did in the Victorian era, they have found ways to achieve symbolic immortality through new digital means. These new memorial methods have not only changed the way people deal with grief, but also redefined the relationship between the individual and society.