Does objective and subjective knowledge vary between opinion leaders and opinion seekers? Implications for wine marketing

Debbie Vigar-Ellis,Leyland Pitt,Albert Caruana
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09571264.2015.1092120
2015-10-02
Journal of Wine Research
Abstract:Wine is a heterogeneous, information-rich offering, with a plethora of brands in the market. Knowledge of wines amidst such diversity understandably varies. In addition, some offer opinions on wine while others seek them. Yet, the interplay between opinion leadership and opinion seeking, on the one hand, and wine knowledge, both objective and subjective, has received little attention by wine marketing researchers. Thus, this paper explores the relationships between opinion leadership and opinion seeking among wine consumers, and investigates whether objective and subjective knowledge varies between opinion leaders and seekers. An online survey was used to collect data on the four constructs and correlation analysis was undertaken to investigate the relationships between them. Key findings indicate that those who tend to seek opinions about wine tend not to have high objective knowledge of wine, as may be expected. On the other hand, opinion leaders think that they know about wine, and generally are objectively knowledgeable. Thus, their influence on others is not only based on communication, but on fact, representing a valuable source of influence for wine marketers. Understanding target consumers’ wine knowledge levels can potentially impact every aspect of wine marketing strategy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether there are differences in wine knowledge between opinion leaders and opinion seekers, specifically including differences in objective and subjective knowledge. The research background is based on the fact that wine is an information - rich and diverse product, and there are significant differences in the knowledge levels of different consumers about wine. Some consumers provide opinions about wine, while others seek these opinions. However, in previous studies, how opinion leadership and opinion - seeking behaviors affect wine knowledge and the relationships between these behaviors and wine knowledge have not received sufficient attention. Therefore, this paper aims to fill this research gap by investigating and analyzing the differences in wine knowledge between opinion leaders and opinion seekers, in order to provide valuable insights for wine marketing strategies. ### Research Methods 1. **Data Collection**: - Data was collected through an online survey, and the survey subjects were wine consumers in the United States. - Respondents were recruited using Amazon.com's MTurk market, and a total of 300 valid questionnaires were collected. 2. **Measurement Tools**: - **Objective Knowledge**: An extended 10 - multiple - choice - question test by Forbes et al. (2008) was used. - **Subjective Knowledge**: An 8 - item scale by Flynn and Goldsmith (1999) was used. - **Opinion Leadership**: A 6 - item scale by Flynn et al. (1996) was used. - **Opinion Seeking**: A 6 - item scale by Flynn et al. (1996) was used. - Demographic information such as the respondents' age, gender, and average weekly wine consumption was also collected. ### Main Findings - **Objective Knowledge**: Opinion seekers usually do not have a high level of objective knowledge, which is as expected. - **Subjective Knowledge**: Opinion leaders think they know a great deal about wine and actually also possess a relatively high level of objective knowledge. - **Relationship between Opinion Leadership and Opinion Seeking**: Opinion leaders not only influence others through communication but also provide opinions based on facts, which makes them an important source of influence in wine marketing. ### Conclusion Understanding the wine knowledge levels of target consumers can potentially influence wine marketing strategies. The influence of opinion leaders in wine purchase decisions is based not only on their communication abilities but also on the knowledge they actually possess. Therefore, wine marketers can improve marketing effectiveness by identifying and utilizing these opinion leaders. ### Formula Example Although this paper mainly involves social science research, in order to meet your requirements, here is a simple formula example to illustrate how to represent a formula in Markdown: Suppose we have a simple linear regression model for predicting wine scores \( y \) based on consumers' objective knowledge \( x \): \[ y=\beta_0 + \beta_1 x+\epsilon \] where: - \( y \) is the wine score - \( x \) is the consumers' objective knowledge - \( \beta_0 \) is the intercept - \( \beta_1 \) is the slope - \( \epsilon \) is the error term Hope this information is helpful to you! If you have any further questions or need more detailed explanations, please feel free to let me know.