A critical interpretive synthesis of interprofessional education interventions
Sanne Kaas-MasonSylvia LangloisSabrina BartlettFarah FriesenStella NgDaniela BellicosoPaula Rowlanda Wilson Centre for Research in Education,University Health Network/University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadab Temerty Faculty of Medicine,Department of Occupational Science and Occupational Therapy,University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadac Curriculum and Faculty Relations,Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education (CACHE),University Health Network and University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadad Curriculum & Education Innovation,Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education (CACHE),University Health Network and University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadae Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education (CACHE),University Health Network and University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadaf Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education,University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadag Dept of Speech-Language Pathology,University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadah Wilson Centre for Research in Education,University of Toronto,Toronto,Canadai The Institute for Education Research,University Health Network,Toronto,Canadaj Interprofessional Practice Based Research,Unity Health Toronto,Toronto,Canadak Wilson Centre for Research in Education and MD Education,University Health Network/University of Toronto,Toronto,CanadaSanne Kaas-Mason is an Education Research Fellow and Kimel-Schatzky Scholar at the Wilson Centre for Research in Education,University Health Network (UHN),where she is working on her PhD in the Health Professions Education Research (HPER) doctoral concentration. She uses critical approaches to investigate how health and social care providers navigate epistemic work interactions with other providers.Sylvia Langlois is the Associate Director,Curriculum and Faculty Relations at the Centre for Advancing Collaborative Practice and Education,University Health Network where she has responsibility for developing,delivering,and evaluating the Interprofessional Education curriculum for approximately 4500 students from 11 health profession programs. Her research interests include curriculum evaluation and patient engagement in education.Sabrina Bartlett is the Manager,Curriculum & Education Innovation at the Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education (CACHE),University of Toronto. Sabrina holds a Masters of Education in Social Justice Education,Ontario Institute for Studies in Education (OISE) and has an interest in examining the social,economic,environmental,historical and cultural contexts in education. She is passionate about exploring critical race praxis and anti-oppressive frameworks/approaches to education practice in order to challenge inequitable power structures.Farah Friesen is Research Associate at the Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education,University of Toronto at University Health Network. Farah is a librarian who has worked in the field of health professions education research for nine years. Farah's main research interest is in critically examining traditional academic performance indicators,encouraging alternative perspectives on metrics,and working towards a broader (re)conceptualization of research and educational impacts.Stella Ng is Director and Scientist at the Centre for Advancing Collaborative Healthcare & Education,University of Toronto at University Health Network. Stella is an education scientist,educator,practitioner,and leader,interested in advancing critical reflection and transformative education toward more collaborative,compassionate,and ethical health care and health science.Daniela Bellicoso is the Research Manager of Interprofessional Practice Based Research at Unity Health Toronto where she provides support and education to health care professionals to develop their clinically based research questions into studies that support the improvement of health care. Her research interests include identifying interprofessional solutions to support and improve team functioning and patient care,as well as burnout and coping among healthcare workers.Paula Rowland is a Scientist with the Wilson Centre and MD Education at the University of Toronto. Having received a PhD in Human and Organizational Systems,her research explores the influence of workplaces on interprofessional care work. She is particularly interested in dynamics of knowledge,power,and identity during organizational change efforts in clinical workplaces.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13561820.2023.2294755
2024-01-08
Journal of Interprofessional Care
Abstract:Interprofessional practice can look quite different depending on a number of dynamics. Interprofessional education interventions may or may not orient toward this range of practice possibilities. This literature review explores: (1) how interprofessional education interventions relate to different kinds of interprofessional practice and (2) the range of interprofessional practices assumed by interprofessional education interventions. Four databases were searched for articles published between 2011–2021 describing pre-licensure level interprofessional education interventions, resulting in a dataset of 110 articles. Our analysis involved (1) descriptive summaries of the articles, and (2) content analysis of the rationale and description of the intervention. Of the articles, 93% (102/110) of interprofessional education interventions were designed and/or evaluated using the concept of interprofessional education competencies. "Teamwork" was the most relied upon competency. Most articles were not explicit about the different kinds of interprofessional practices that these competencies might be oriented toward. Our study substantiates earlier claims that interprofessional education literature tends to focus on competencies and orient toward undifferentiated understandings of "teamwork." This analysis is particularly important as interprofessional teams are engaging in increasingly complex, fluid, and distributed forms of interprofessional practice that may not be captured in an undifferentiated approach to "teamwork."
health care sciences & services,health policy & services