Precipitation and elephants, not fire, shape tree community composition in Serengeti National Park, Tanzania

Deusdedith M. Rugemalila,Todd M. Anderson,Ricardo M. Holdo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/btp.12311
2016-01-29
Biotropica
Abstract:Abstract Savannas are spatially diverse, variable and are susceptible to high rates of disturbance from fire and herbivory. There is significant interest in woody cover dynamics in relation to disturbance regimes. Less effort has been devoted to understand processes that drive tree community composition. In this study, tree species composition data collected at the landscape scale in the Serengeti were used to identify key environmental factors driving variation in species composition. A system of 38 plots clustered within 10 sites spanning the mean annual precipitation ( MAP ) gradient was used to assess the relative role of bottom‐up (precipitation, soil nutrients and soil texture) vs. top‐down factors (fire and elephant herbivory) on tree community composition. We developed candidate models relating tree species composition (based on multivariate community analysis) to different combinations of plot‐level environmental covariates. Results suggest that tree community composition is largely driven by MAP and is associated with elephant population density. Strikingly, we found no evidence that fire influences species compositional turnover. In a second analysis, we used structural equation model ( SEM ) to explore the possible direction of association between elephant density and tree species composition. We compared a model that included elephant effects on composition to one that included community composition effects on elephant density. Results suggest that variation in elephant population density across space is more likely to drive tree community composition and not vice versa . We propose that precipitation and herbivory, rather than fire, determine tree species composition in Serengeti Acacia tree community. IKISIRI Uoto savana (mbuga) hutofautiana sana, na mimea ipatikanayo katika uoto huo husumbuliwa kwa kiwango kikubwa cha moto na wanyama wala mimea. Kumekuwa na juhudi kubwa za kutafiti mabadiliko ya msongamano wa miti na uwiano kati ya miti na nyasi kuhusiana na usumbufu huo. Juhudi kidogo zimeelekezwa katika kuelewa vyanzo vya kutofautiana kwa aina ya miti. Katika utafiti huu, takwimu za aina ya miti zilizokusanywa katika hifadhi ya Taifa ya Serengeti zilitumika kubaini vyanzo muhimu vya ki‐mazingira ambavyo vinaweza kusababisha kutofautina kwa aina ya miti katika maeneo mbalimbali. Mfumo wa viwanja 38 vilivyoenea katika maeneo 10 tofauti hifadhini Serengeti ambayo hupata viwango tofauti vya mvua kila mwaka ulitumika kutathmini jukumu la visababishi chini ‐juu (mfano; unyevu, rutuba na unamu wa udongo) dhidi ya visababishi juu‐chini (mfano; moto na uharibifu usababishwao na tembo) katika kuchochea utofauti wa jamii (aina) ya miti. Tulitengeneza miundo takwimu inayoweza kutofautisha sababu zinazosababisha mchanganyiko wa aina ya miti (kwa kutumia uchambuzi mchangamano) na michanganyiko tofauti ya vielelezo ngazi ya viwanja. Matokeo yanaonesha kwamba utofauti wa aina ya miti kwa kiasi kikubwa husababishwa na kiwango cha unyevu, na kuhusishwa na wiani ya tembo. Kinyume na matarajio, tuligundua kwamba moto una mchango mdogo sana katika kubadili aina ya miti ndani ya mbuga ya Serengeti. Pia tulitumia uchambuzi muundo mling'anyo (structural equation model) kuchunguza mwelekeo wa uhusiano kati ya wiani ya tembo na aina ya miti. Matokeo yanaonesha kwamba tofauti katika wiani ya tembo hubadilisha jamii ya miti na sio kinyume chake. Tunapendekeza kwamba unyevu na wanyama wala mimea, na sio moto, huchangia sana katika kuchagiza miti jamii ya migunga ndani ya hifadhi ya Serengeti.
ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?