Abstract:Marine protected areas (MPAs) are growing in popularity as a conservation tool, and there are increasing calls for additional MPAs. Meta-analyses indicate that most MPAs successfully meet the minimal goal of increasing biomass inside the MPA, while some do not, leaving open the important question of what makes MPAs successful. An often-overlooked aspect of this problem is that the success of fishery management outside MPA boundaries (i.e., whether a population is overfished) affects how well MPAs meet both conservation goals (e.g., increased biomass) and economic goals (e.g., minimal negative effects on fishery yield). Using a simple example of a system with homogeneous habitat and periodically spaced MPAs, we show that, as area in MPAs increases, (1) conservation value (biomass) may initially be zero, implying no benefit, then at some point increases monotonically; and (2) fishery yield may be zero, then increases monotonically to a maximum beyond which further increase in MPA area causes yield to decline. Importantly, the points at which these changes in slope occur vary among species and depend on management outside MPAs. Decision makers considering the effects of a potential system of MPAs on multiple species are confronted by a number of such cost-benefit curves, and it is usually impossible to maximize benefits and minimize costs for all species. Moreover, the precise shape of each curve is unknown due to uncertainty regarding the fishery status of each species. Here we describe a decision-analytic approach that incorporates existing information on fishery stock status to present decision makers with the range of likely outcomes of MPA implementation. To summarize results from many species whose overfishing status is uncertain, our decision-analysis approach involves weighted averages over both overfishing uncertainty and species. In an example from an MPA decision process in California, USA, an optimistic projection of future fishery management success led to recommendation of fewer and smaller MPAs than that derived from a more pessimistic projection of future management success. This example illustrates how information on fishery status can be used to project potential outcomes of MPA implementation within a decision analysis framework and highlights the need for better population information.

Implementing Article 28 of the UN Fish Stocks Agreement: The First Review of a Conservation Measure in the South Pacific Regional Fisheries Management Organisation

Assessing progress in data reporting by tuna Regional Fisheries Management Organizations

Advancing tuna catch allocation negotiations: an analysis of sovereign rights and fisheries access arrangements

The Objection by the Republic of Ecuador to a Decision of the Commission of the South Pacific Regional Fisheries Organisation

Subsidies and allocation: A legacy of distortion and intergenerational loss

Enhancing cooperative responses by regional fisheries management organisations to climate-driven redistribution of tropical Pacific tuna stocks

The Recovery of Atlantic Swordfish: The Comparative Roles of the Regional Fisheries Management Organization and Species Biology

Scientific Research and Its Influence in Decision-Making of Tuna Regional Fisheries Management Organizations: Case Studies in the Atlantic Ocean and Indian Ocean

Addressing illegal longlining and ghost fishing in the Galapagos marine reserve: an overview of challenges and potential solutions

Ex-post evaluation of fishery management policies on wild fisheries production in northern Cabo Verde: An example of mackerel scad (Decapterus macarellus, Carangidae)

Cetacean bycatch management in regional fisheries management organizations: Current progress, gaps, and looking ahead

Effective fisheries management instrumental in improving fish stock status

CHANGING SELECTIVITY PATTERNS IN THE WESTERN ATLANTIC BLUEFIN TUNA FISHERY: IMPACTS ON MANAGEMENT TARGETS

DOCUMENT IATTC-87 INF-B DEVELOPING CONSERVATION MEASURES FOR BLUEFIN TUNA IN THE EASTERN AND WESTERN REGIONS OF THE PACIFIC OCEAN: FACTORS TO CONSIDER AND FISHERY IMPACT ANALYSIS

Optimising the review of electronic monitoring information for management of commercial fisheries

Sustainable reference points for multispecies coral reef fisheries

Assessing of a portion of the Pacific Thunnus albacares stock: Ahi in the Main Hawaiian Islands

Evaluating the Effects of a Deep-Water Marine Protected Area a Decade After Closure: A Multifaceted Approach Reveals Equivocal Benefits to Reef Fish Populations

Decision analysis for designing marine protected areas for multiple species with uncertain fishery status

Stock Assessment and Overexploitation Risk of Small Pelagic Fish in Fisheries Management Area 715 of Indonesia

Macroeconomic impact of an international fishery regulation on a small island country