Release strategies and ecological factors influence mitigation translocation outcomes for burrowing owls: a comparative evaluation

S. M. Hennessy,C. L. Wisinski,N. A. Ronan,C. J. Gregory,R. R. Swaisgood,L. A. Nordstrom
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/acv.12767
2022-01-27
Animal Conservation
Abstract:Abstract Mitigation translocations are increasing and if they are to fulfill their regulatory intent, the application of best‐practice principles to release strategy and monitoring is required. With an investment of 3 years, we engaged with stakeholders, including developers, to improve outcomes from mitigation translocations of an at‐risk species, the western burrowing owl Athene cunicularia hypugaea (BUOW). We evaluated the consequences of two primary translocation methods, displacement (i.e. exclusion from burrow) and translocation, against control owls, using a suite of success metrics focused on dispersal, survival and reproduction. We also tested the provision of visual and acoustic conspecific cues to dampen dispersal away from release sites. Within the displaced group, BUOW settled closer to the origin site if burrows were available nearby. Although translocated BUOW dispersed farther from the release site than displaced BUOW, this difference disappeared when conspecific cues were present. BUOW were 20 times more likely to settle at the release site when conspecifics or their cues were present. Translocating animals over longer distances (>17.5 km) reduced the incidence of BUOW returning to the origin site. When avoiding direct impacts to BUOW is not feasible, a determination of the most beneficial translocation method must be made, driven by site‐specific conditions and the feasibility of implementing best management practices. The known costs of translocation to survival may be offset by long‐term advantages such as the establishment of breeding populations inside protected areas. Mitigation translocations can benefit from carefully devised and tested hypotheses to determine what works and what does not; we advocate the increased use of evidence in mitigation translocation to guide management decisions and policies.
biodiversity conservation,ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?