Abstract:The UK NHS has a number of important strengths. Its costs are relatively low compared to the health care systems of other developed countries due in part to cash limited central budgeting. It is extremely popular with the electorate and surveys show overall satisfaction with the NHS despite some dissatisfaction with waiting lists and a public perception of underfunding. The NHS model of general medical care provided by independent contractors has been acclaimed as "a British success" (General Medical Services Council, 1983). The role of the UK GP combines providing primary care and acting as a gatekeeper to secondary care. This increases equitable access to care for the population and assists in cost containment. As a model, it is currently being emulated in other countries including Sweden and US Health Maintenance Organizations but, as in these countries, the UK primary care model has been evaluated poorly. There are of course continuing weaknesses in the UK health care system. There is insufficient knowledge upon which to base health care services and increase efficiency. In the future, if a knowledge-based health care service is to be created, a considerable amount of research and evaluation is required to identify "what works" in health care (i.e., what is effective) and also the cost effective ways of altering provider behaviour to maximise the amount of health gain which can be achieved using a limited budget. The NHS reforms created a lot of enthusiasm and energy but its effects are difficult to disentangle from the simultaneous increases in funding. There is little evidence from the UK or elsewhere that competition in health care produces efficiency or improvements in resource allocation. Evaluation is required to identify which of the reforms are increasing efficiency. Competition needs to be used with caution and recognised as a mean and not an end in itself. It is remarkable how both clinical practice and health policy reform, in the UK and elsewhere, is poorly evaluated. Medical practice varies substantially locally, regionally, and internationally, e.g., patients with similar age and stage of cancer receive very different levels of radiotherapy across Europe. For most interventions, the appropriate level of treatment may be asserted but is not based on cost effectiveness knowledge. Health policy analysts, like clinicians, make assertions about competition and other health care reforms which are value- rather than knowledge-based. Both groups of decision-makers should be more cautious, informing their choices with research rather than relying on unsubstantiated optimism!

Service improvement in the English National health service: Complexities and tensions

Assessing the new public management: the case of the National Health Service.

Universal coverage and cost control: the United Kingdom National Health Service

Best practice organizational effectiveness in NHS Trusts. Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. Case study

Constructing notions of healthcare productivity: the call for a new professionalism?

The British NHS at 75: Past, Contemporary, and Future Challenges

Best practice organisational effectiveness in NHS Trusts. Allington NHS Trust case study

Reducing inequality in avoidable emergency admissions: Case studies of local health care systems in England using a realist approach

From assurance to coproduction: a century of improving the quality of health-care service

RESTRUCTURING THE NHS AGAIN: SUPPLY SIDE REFORM IN RECENT ENGLISH HEALTH CARE POLICY

Reframing the public/private debate on healthcare services: Tracking boundaries in the National Health Service

Advancing the digital and computational capabilities of healthcare providers: A qualitative study of a hospital organisation in the NHS

How to do better health reform: a snapshot of change and improvement initiatives in the health systems of 30 countries

Reforming emergency care: Primary Care Trust power in action research

An economic analysis of the limits of market based reforms in the English NHS

Achieving high-quality universal health coverage: a perspective from the National Health Service in England

Standardising costs or standardising care? Qualitative evaluation of the implementation and impact of a hospital funding reform in Ontario, Canada

Vertical Integration in Healthcare and Patient Satisfaction: An Exploratory Analysis of Portuguese Reforms

Improving the quality of NHS out-patient clinics: the applications and misapplications of TQM

Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose: senior NHS managers' narratives of restructuring

Efficiency and equity implications of the health care reforms