Abstract:Monitoring within-field crop variability at fine spatial and temporal resolution can assist farmers in making reliable decisions during their agricultural management; however, it traditionally involves a labor-intensive and time-consuming pointwise manual process. To the best of our knowledge, few studies conducted a comparison of Sentinel-2 with UAV data for crop monitoring in the context of precision agriculture. Therefore, prospects of crop monitoring for characterizing biophysical plant parameters and leaf nitrogen of wheat and barley crops were evaluated from a more practical viewpoint closer to agricultural routines. Multispectral UAV and Sentinel-2 imagery was collected over three dates in the season and compared with reference data collected at 20 sample points for plant leaf nitrogen (N), maximum plant height, mean plant height, leaf area index (LAI), and fresh biomass. Higher correlations of UAV data to the agronomic parameters were found on average than with Sentinel-2 data with a percentage increase of 6.3% for wheat and 22.2% for barley. In this regard, VIs calculated from spectral bands in the visible part performed worse for Sentinel-2 than for the UAV data. In addition, large-scale patterns, formed by the influence of an old riverbed on plant growth, were recognizable even in the Sentinel-2 imagery despite its much lower spatial resolution. Interestingly, also smaller features, such as the tramlines from controlled traffic farming (CTF), had an influence on the Sentinel-2 data and showed a systematic pattern that affected even semivariogram calculation. In conclusion, Sentinel-2 imagery is able to capture the same large-scale pattern as can be derived from the higher detailed UAV imagery; however, it is at the same time influenced by management-driven features such as tramlines, which cannot be accurately georeferenced. In consequence, agronomic parameters were better correlated with UAV than with Sentinel-2 data. Crop growers as well as data providers from remote sensing services may take advantage of this knowledge and we recommend the use of UAV data as it gives additional information about management-driven features. For future perspective, we would advise fusing UAV with Sentinel-2 imagery taken early in the season as it can integrate the effect of agricultural management in the subsequent absence of high spatial resolution data to help improve crop monitoring for the farmer and to reduce costs.

Comparative Evaluation of Land Surface Temperature Images from Unmanned Aerial Vehicle and Satellite Observation for Agricultural Areas Using In Situ Data

An Improved UAV-Based ATI Method Incorporating Solar Radiation for Farm-Scale Bare Soil Moisture Measurement

Verification of Accuracy of Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Land Surface Temperature Images Using In-Situ Data

Comparison of Accuracy of Surface Temperature Images from Unmanned Aerial Vehicle and Satellite for Precise Thermal Environment Monitoring of Urban Parks Using In Situ Data

A Land Surface Temperature Retrieval Method for UAV Broadband Thermal Imager Data

A retrieval method for land surface temperatures based on UAV broadband thermal infrared images via the three-dimensional look-up table

Small unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV)-based detection of seasonal micro-urban heat islands for diverse land uses

Crop Monitoring Using Sentinel-2 and UAV Multispectral Imagery: A Comparison Case Study in Northeastern Germany

A Comparison of Crop Parameters Estimation Using Images from UAV-Mounted Snapshot Hyperspectral Sensor and High-Definition Digital Camera

Removing Temperature Drift and Temporal Variation in Thermal Infrared Images of a UAV Uncooled Thermal Infrared Imager

Temperature Accuracy Analysis of Land Cover Around Urban Rivers Using Thermal Infrared Sensor–Mounted UAV

Mapping Super High Resolution Evapotranspiration in Oasis-Desert Areas Using UAV Multi-Sensor Data

UAV-based remote sensing in plant stress imagine using high-resolution thermal sensor for digital agriculture practices: a meta-review

A Multi-Scale Observation Experiment on Land Surface Temperature Using UAV Remote Sensing (MUSOES-UAV): Preliminary Results

Estimation of Crop Transpiration and Its Scale Effect Based on Ground and UAV Thermal Infrared Remote Sensing Images

Evaluation of UAV-based Drought Indices for Crop Water Conditions Monitoring: A Case Study of Summer Maize

A physical-based atmospheric correction algorithm of unmanned aerial vehicles images and its utility analysis

Estimation of Wheat LAI at Middle to High Levels Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Narrowband Multispectral Imagery

Actual Evapotranspiration from UAV Images: A Multi-Sensor Data Fusion Approach

Experimental Evaluation and Consistency Comparison of UAV Multispectral Minisensors

Evapotranspiration Estimation with Small UAVs in Precision Agriculture