Abstract:Journal of Interpersonal Violence, Ahead of Print. Sexual violence (SV), which causes sexual harm, is a significant public health issue globally. In many nations, conventional legal remedies are the prevailing responses to SV. Restorative justice (RJ) shows promise as a potential alternative way to address sexual harm, given evidence that RJ better aligns with expressed needs and safety concerns of those directly impacted by SV. However, few empirical studies exist concerning best practices for and the effectiveness of using RJ for this purpose. This study helped address this research gap by conducting in-depth interviews to understand how organizations choose to use RJ to address sexual harm; how RJ is being operationalized to address sexual harm; how those involved in offering RJ to address sexual harm define success or positive outcomes; and factors that present challenges for or contribute to the success of RJ processes addressing sexual harm. We conducted 24 semi-structured key informant interviews with RJ practitioners and researchers in six countries. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and emergent themes were identified through a rigorous, iterative coding process. Informants discussed using formal RJ practices with a subset of sexual harm cases, typically instances of adult sexual assault or to resolve sexual harm adults experienced as children. These responses generally adhered to this sequence: referral, assessing appropriateness for participation, preparing participants, and conducting the process. Informants shared anecdotal examples of RJ benefits and measurable indicators of program success like participant satisfaction, increased coping skills, and signs that harm will not recur, although, most were not formally evaluating their programs. Challenges included limited resources, unsupportive RJ-related beliefs, and COVID-19. Factors that aid success include funding, partnerships, and positive RJ-related views. Study findings underscore the need for more research on using RJ to address sexual harm with exploration of best practices for delivering such services to diverse communities.

“And focused upon victims’ needs”: towards an assessment of the victim-friendly principles of restorative justice practice

Victim involvement in forensic psychiatric treatment: opportunities and challenges from a restorative justice perspective

Restorative Justice as Social Justice for Victims of Gendered Violence: A Standpoint Feminist Perspective

The exclusion of serious and organised offenders and their victims from the offer of restorative justice: Should this be so and what happens when the offer is put on the table?

"Obviously It's for the Victim to Decide": Restorative Justice for Sexual and Family Violence From the Perspective of Second-Wave Anti-Rape Activists

From parallel to intersecting narratives in cases of sexual assault

The Exclusion of Serious and Organised Offenders and their Victims from the Offer of Restorative Justice

Restorative justice conferencing in an environmental offending context: the role of legislation

Voice, neutrality and respect: Use of Victim Support services, procedural fairness and confidence in the criminal justice system

Restorative justice informed criminal justice social work and probation services

Seeking justice rooted in truth, reconciliation and forgiveness

Has Probation Any Impact in Terms of Reparation to Victims and Communities? Complicating a Simple Question

Victim participation in criminal justice: A quantitative systematic and critical literature review

Transforming Communities: Restorative Justice as a Community Building Strategy

Restorative Just Culture: An Exploration of the Enabling Conditions for Successful Implementation

The Transformative Potential of Restorative Justice: What the Mainstream Can Learn from the Margins

What Is Wrong with Empirical-Legal Research into Victimhood? A Critical Analysis of the Ordered Apology and the Victim Impact Statement

Victim Welfare, Social Harmony, and State Interests: Implementing Restorative Justice in Chinese Environmental Criminal Justice

A Relational Conception of Justice: The Theory of Recognition and Moral Injury -Proposals for a Practical Evaluative Framework-

A Procedural Justice Theory Approach to Police Engagement with Victim-Survivors of Rape and Sexual Assault: Initial Findings of the ‘Project Bluestone’ Pilot Study

Using Restorative Justice to Respond to and Prevent Sexual Harm: A Qualitative Study of Formal Practices in Six Countries