Affect, Emotion, and Children's Literature: Representation and Socialization in Texts for Children and Young Adults ed. by Kristine Moruzi, Michelle J. Smith, and Elizabeth Bullen (review)
Frances Bottenberg
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/bkb.2019.0010
2019-01-31
Bookbird: A Journal of International Children's Literature
Abstract:YA fiction and films, including Chaos Walking, Delirium, and Frozen. What the contributions collectively uncover is that no text is innocent when it comes to enlisting young readers’ affective or emotional responses for the transmission of meanings, messages, and lessons. Some such cases, as when a reader’s empathic imagination is developed through contact with a likeable protagonist who nonetheless is importantly unlike the reader, will not strike us as troubling. Other cases are not so easy: for instance, as several authors in the collection note, recent YA dystopian writing tends toward a trope wherein a lead character commits a morally ambiguous, or even obviously wrong, act for ostensibly selfish or preferentialist reasons, as when many innocents are sacrificed to save the life of a single or a few loved ones. What meanings are young hearts and minds making from such narratives? The volume is divided into four sections. The essays featured in the first section, “Affect and the Historical Child Reader,” take up cases of historical children’s literature intentionally crafted to co-opt readers’ affective responses for socialization purposes or for the sake of moral education. Emotions such as shame, pity, empathy, and self-confidence are particularly in the spotlight. The second section, “Theory of Mind,” contains three essays that delve into works aiming to build young readers’ “mind-reading” abilities, that is, the act of modeling another’s state of mind for the sake of understanding their intentions and action motivations. Concerns are justly raised regarding the moral risks involved in creating characters whom teens identify affectively with, since these characters become quasi-role models. As fictional characters, though, they often remain psychologically oversimplified and behaviorally constrained by storytelling artifices. The third section, “Place and Space,” features essays that show how affect and emotion must be localized to be most effective on young readers—that is, embedded into specific spatiotemporal, existentially weighted, and socially meaningful scenes. children’s literature. It demonstrates how historical events continue to impact social conditions and questions of cultural identity, and how literary works, to this day, still reflect them, consciously or unconsciously. For future research, it would be interesting to extend the scope of this study to include more contemporary works, explicitly aimed at children, to see whether and how they perpetuate the double bind diagnosed by González.
Sociology,Education