Educational Tracking and the Feminized Classroom: A Little Princess and The Secret Garden

Christopher Parkes
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137265098_6
2012-01-01
Abstract:The first half of Charlotte Bronte’s Jane Eyre is a Cinderella story set in a charity school that uses oppressive methods of discipline and control to maintain its pupils as a subservient underclass. Within the walls of Lowood Institution, which is run by the evil Mr Brocklehurst, children who are the product of poor families are trained to become docile and obedient so that when they leave they will take their place as servants within the homes of the wealthy. Because Jane is unlike the other pupils, because she is from a family of middle-class professionals, she has a strong sense of pride that makes her better able to resist the school’s brainwashing and better able to acquire the skills that eventually allow her to become a schoolteacher. It is not only her own strength of character that helps her to regain her lost social status but the benevolent Miss Temple who brings a kinder, gentler educational philosophy to the school, one that allows a gifted student like Jane to realize her potential.1 If Lowood forces Jane into the role of a servant, the care and sympathy of her female teacher allows her to acquire the skills necessary to achieve social mobility. In this way, Bronte’s fairytale plot replaces the fairy godmother with a career woman who inspires the long-suffering Cinderella figure to aspire to an influential social role. Throughout the nineteenth century, the British school system continued to be based upon the kind of social control experienced by Jane—the directing of children into social roles based on race, class, and gender or what is now referred to as tracking or streaming.2
What problem does this paper attempt to address?