Abstract:Multiple experimental evolution studies on Drosophila melanogaster in the 1980s and 1990s indicated that enhanced competitive ability evolved primarily through increased larval tolerance to nitrogenous wastes and increased larval feeding and foraging rate, at the cost of efficiency of food conversion to biomass, and this became the widely accepted view of how adaptation to larval crowding evolves in fruitflies. We recently showed that populations of D. ananassae and D. n. nasuta subjected to extreme larval crowding evolved greater competitive ability without evolving higher feeding rates, primarily through a combination of reduced larval duration, faster attainment of minimum critical size for pupation, greater efficiency of food conversion to biomass, increased pupation height and, perhaps, greater urea/ammonia tolerance. This was a very different suite of traits than that seen to evolve under similar selection in D. melanogaster and was closer to the expectations from the theory of K-selection. At that time, we suggested two possible reasons for the differences in the phenotypic correlates of greater competitive ability seen in the studies with D. melanogaster and the other two species. First, that D. ananassae and D. n. nasuta had a very different genetic architecture of traits affecting competitive ability compared to the long-term laboratory populations of D. melanogaster used in the earlier studies, either because the populations of the former two species were relatively recently wild-caught, or by virtue of being different species. Second, that the different evolutionary trajectories in D. ananassae and D. n. nasuta versus D. melanogaster were a reflection of differences in the manner in which larval crowding was imposed in the two sets of selection experiments. The D. melanogaster studies used a higher absolute density of eggs per unit volume of food, and a substantially larger total volume of food, than the studies on D. ananassae and D. n. nasuta. Here, we show that long-term laboratory populations of D. melanogaster, descended from some of the populations used in the earlier studies, evolve essentially the same set of traits as the D. ananassae and D. n. nasuta crowding-adapted populations when subjected to a similar larval density at low absolute volumes of food. As in the case of D. ananassae and D. n. nasuta, and in stark contrast to earlier studies with D. melanogaster, these crowding-adapted populations of D. melanogaster did not evolve greater larval feeding rates as a correlate of increased competitive ability. The present results clearly suggest that the suite of phenotypes through which the evolution of greater competitive ability is achieved in fruitflies depends critically not just on larval density per unit volume of food, but also on the total amount of food available in the culture vials. We discuss these results in the context of an hypothesis about how larval density and the height of the food column in culture vials might interact to alter the fitness costs and benefits of increased larval feeding rates, thus resulting in different routes to the evolution of greater competitive ability, depending on the details of exactly how the larval crowding was implemented.

Evolution of increased larval competitive ability in Drosophila melanogaster without increased larval feeding rate

Density-dependent selection in Drosophila: evolution of egg size and hatching time

Experimental evolution of metabolism under nutrient restriction: enhanced amino acid catabolism and a key role of branched-chain amino acids

Adaptation to yeast restriction through the evolution of resource acquisition, macronutrient reserve, and ovarian function

Density dependent development in pest and domestic Drosophilidae species

Diet‐induced plasticity of life‐history traits and gene expression in outbred Drosophila melanogaster population

High-fat and high-sugar diets induce rapid adaptations of fat storage in the house fly Musca domestica L.

Experimental evolution under combined thermal-nutritional stress in Drosophila melanogaster results in evolved shifts in larval thermotolerance and thermal plasticity

Natural and Artificial Selection for Parasitoid Resistance in Drosophila melanogaster Leave Different Genetic Signatures

Additive and context-dependent effects of developmental and adult diet on life-history traits and their associations in outbred population

Defense traits of larval Drosophila melanogaster exhibit genetically based trade-offs against different species of parasitoids

Genetic Variation in Trophic Avoidance Behaviour Shows Fruit Flies are Generally Attracted to Bacterial Substrates

Larval protein restriction interacts with adult diet to increase fitness in an outbred multiparent population

Selection on female reproductive schedules in the marula fly, Ceratitis cosyra (Diptera: Tephritidae) affects dietary optima for female reproductive traits but not lifespan

Evolution and development of Drosophila melanogaster under different thermal conditions affected cell sizes and sensitivity to paralyzing hypoxia

Shorter effective lifespan in laboratory populations of D. melanogaster might reduce sexual selection

Ruling the unruly: Innovation in ant larval feeding led to increased caste dimorphism and social complexity

Developmental Environment Effects on Sexual Selection in Male and Female Drosophila melanogaster

Evolution of resistance and disease tolerance mechanisms to oral bacterial infection in D. melanogaster

Experimental evolution for improved post-infection survival selects for increased disease resistance in Drosophila melanogaster

Socially plastic responses in females are robust to evolutionary manipulations of adult sex ratio and adult nutrition