A comparison of award‐winning radio commercials and their day‐to‐day counterparts

Norman Felsenthal,G. Wayne Shamo,John R. Bittner
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/08838157109363650
1971-06-01
Journal of Broadcasting
Abstract:What are some of the differences between award‐winning radio commercials and those that are judged by those in the trade not to be worthy of an award such as the “CLIO” of the American TV and Radio Commercials Festival? Should music and sound effects be used? What are some of the objectively measured stylistic devices used in the text of each spot? How “listenable” are they? In the following article, research into these matters leads to a number of “do's” and “don'ts"—and a warning that winning awards may not be nearly as important as selling goods and services. Drs. Norman Felsenthal (Ph.D., University of Iowa) and G. Wayne Shamo (Ph.D., Southern Illinois University) are assistant professors in the Department of Communication at Purdue University; Mr. John R. Bittner is a graduate assistant and doctoral candidate in the same department, and news director of WAZY, Lafayette, Indiana.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?