Ecosystem Approaches to River Basin Planning

Peter J. Reynolds

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-009-5458-8_5

1985-01-01

Abstract:Over the past two decades there have been many versions of the “ecosystem approach”. Much of the work has been abstract and relatively difficult to implement by decision-makers. Most of these approaches share the following characteristics: a primary focus on ecological phenomena as opposed to engineering, economic, or jurisdictional phenomena; a perception of some self-regulatory capacity on the part of an ecosystem; a recognition of the marked responsiveness of many ecological systems to natural and human activities; and a readiness to strike a pragmatic compromise between detailed reductionistic understanding and more comprehensive, holistic meaning. In the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence River Basin, workers are now trying to implement operational and institutional forms of ecosystem approach. Ten of these initiatives are assessed here, taken from all government levels, directed toward river basin, open lake, coastal, and hinterland components of the basin. This comparison illustrates the range of proposals now under consideration in the basin and identifies their common elements. These features are offered as a definition of the criteria involved in an ecosystem approach. It is suggested that flexible eclectic pragmatism may be the most productive attitude toward Great Lakes environmental problems.