Abstract:This paper has two distinct but related goals: (1) to identify some of the potential consequences of the Internet for our cognitive abilities and (2) to suggest an approach to evaluate these consequences. I begin by outlining the Google effect, which (allegedly) shows that when we know information is available online, we put less effort into storing that information in the brain. Some argue that this strategy is adaptive because it frees up internal resources which can then be used for other cognitive tasks, whereas others argue that this is maladaptive because it makes us less knowledgeable. I argue that the currently available empirical evidence in cognitive psychology does not support strong conclusions about the negative effects of the Internet on memory. Before we can make value-judgements about the cognitive effects of the Internet, we need more robust and ecologically-valid evidence. Having sketched a more nuanced picture of the Google effect, I then argue that the value of our cognitive abilities is in part intrinsic and in part instrumental, that is, they are both valuable in themselves and determined by the socio-cultural context in which these cognitive abilities are utilised. Focussing on instrumental value, I argue that, in an information society such as ours, having the skills to efficiently navigate, evaluate, compare, and synthesize online information are (under most circumstances) more valuable than having a lot of facts stored in biological memory. This is so, partly because using the Internet as an external memory system has overall benefits for education, navigation, journalism, and academic scholarship.

People mistake the internet’s knowledge for their own

Search Fluency Mistaken for Understanding: Ease of Information Retrieval from the Internet Inflates Internal Knowledge Confidence

Google effects on memory: a meta-analytical review of the media effects of intensive Internet search behavior

Individual Inferences in Web-Based Information Environments: How Cognitive Processing Fluency, Information Access, Active Search Behaviors, and Task Competency Affect Metacognitive and Task Judgments

The Internet, Cognitive Enhancement, and the Values of Cognition

Laypeople's beliefs about the effects of common estimator variables on memory

How does Google get its information?: Children's judgements about Google search

The "curse of knowledge" when predicting others' knowledge

When the internet is wrong: Children's trust in an inaccurate internet or human source

Fooling with facts: Quantifying anchoring bias through a large-scale online experiment

Children weigh internet inaccuracy when trusting in online information

The Impacts of Internet Knowledge on College Students' Intention to Continue to Use the Internet.

Relying on External Information Sources When Answering Knowledge Questions in Web Surveys

Stuck in the Wisdom of Crowds: Information, Knowledge, and Heuristics

Metacognitive phenomena during human–Internet interactions

Humans rely more on algorithms than social influence as a task becomes more difficult

Misplaced trust? The relationship between trust, ability to identify commercially influenced results, and search engine preference

The Impact of Internet Knowledge on Internet Users Intention-. A Case of the College Students

Online searches to evaluate misinformation can increase its perceived veracity

Internet usage and patient's trust in physician during diagnoses: A knowledge power perspective