Abstract:Abstract This paper explores the concept of legal translation as a Third Space through the lens of the ‘multilingual’ Court of Justice of the European Union (ECJ). In many ways legal translation at that Court fits readily with the characterisation of translation as a Third Space. Due to complex internal production processes the ECJ produces texts which are undoubtedly hybrid in nature, and which exhibit distinctive features on a lexical and textual level marking them out as a product of cross-fertilisation of influences from source and target languages and legal cultures. Even the teleological approach taken towards legal reasoning at the ECJ occupies a space outside the strict confines of the texts involved. Both the processes and the product of the ECJ’s language system appear to bear all the hallmarks of translation as a Third Space. However, translation at the ECJ also challenges the concept of a Third Space. The prevailing definitions of translation as a Third Space fail to effectively conceptualise additional nuances of the specific nature of drafting and the complex nature of translation at the ECJ. This paper uses original empirical data to demonstrate that translation at the ECJ places constraints on the undefined, vague and fluid nature of the Third Space, warping the forces at work within that space. In this regard, rather than an amorphous space, the Third Space is better thought of as a determinate area which is delimited by elements of translation process which constrain it. This adapted framing of the Third Space can consequently be used to better understand and illustrate the dynamics at play in other areas of legal translation where the current concept of the Third Space is equally inadequate for encompassing the specific nature of translation practices which impact on that space-in-between.

Towards a linguistic theory of translation as re-contextualisation and a Third Space phenomenon

Reconceptualising the Third Space of Legal Translation: A Study of the Court of Justice of the European Union

Beyond Translation Proper—Extending the Field of Translation Studies

Third Space of Legal Translation: Between Protean Meanings, Legal Cultures and Communication Stratification

Outlining a new linguistic theory of translation

Community Translation: Translation as a social activity and its possible consequences in the advent of Web 2.0 and beyond

Beyond theory and practice: towards an ethics of translation

Towards a Text-World Approach to Translation and Its Pedagogical Implications

The conceptualisation of translation in translation studies: a response

Rethinking translation studies

Praxis and process meet halfway: The convergence of sociological and cognitive approaches in translation studies

Cognitive Linguistics and Translation Studies

For a translational sociology: Illuminating translation in society, theory and research

Translation Studies

Theorizing Translatology: Toward an Interdisciplinary Approach

Translation Theory ‘Translated’: Three Perspectives on Translation in Organizational Research

Repositioning English and multilingualism in English as a Lingua Franca

Pragmatics in Translation

Translating meaning as cognitive socio-cultural systems.A conceptual approach to the translation of plurilingualism in postcolonial literary discourse in Portuguese

Translation Principles in Modern Cognitive Paradigm

Do People Only Create in Their Mother Tongue? Schleiermacher’s Argument Against the “Naturalizing” Method of Translation, From Today’s Point of View