M51’s Material Arms and Density Waves

G. G. Byrd,S. Howard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-75273-5_24

1990-01-01

Abstract:We find that the entire spiral structure in M51 is consistent with a tidal passage of its companion, NGC 5195, in a highly inclined orbit ≈ 70 million years ago. Fig. 1 shows dust lane arms of M51 from a photograph. Azimuths and radii of observed arms ”time reversed” back to 70 million years ago are seen as two straight lines which point to the hypothesized disk crossing point of the companion to the northwest. This direction agrees with that found in Toomre and Toomre’s (1972) non-self-gravitating simulations. Fig. 2 is a preliminary self-gravitating computer simulation of M51 including disk gas cloud collisional dissipation and gravitational clumping. Disk gas arms (representing HI, H2) are shown at the present epoch. Compare to the observed dust lane arms in Fig. 1, noting the steepness of the outer arms, their symmetric kinks going inward and the size of the pattern relative to companion position. Note the long arm opposite the present companion position and the ”sling shot” gas feature above the present position of the companion in the simulations. Compare to the HI observations of Rots, et al. elsewhere in this volume. The companion passed near the disk edge to the northwest as marked. Compare to the line direction in Fig. 1. The companion then moved beyond the disk plane to its present position seen through M51’s disk. Fig. 3 shows an unperturbed disk (to a different scale) at the same time step as Fig. 2. This essential numerical test shows no large changes in structure or spontaneous spiral arms. The Fig. 2 outer arms wind up like material arms. The arm particles originated in a roughly fan-shaped region around a line from the crossing-point to the nucleus.