Abstract:BACKGROUND Patient monitoring is indispensable in any operating room to follow the patient’s current health state based on measured physiological parameters. Reducing workload helps to free cognitive resources and thus influences human performance, which ultimately improves the quality of care. Among the many methods available to assess perceived workload, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration Task Load Index (NASA-TLX) provides the most widely accepted tool. However, only few studies have investigated the validity of the NASA-TLX in the health care sector. OBJECTIVE This study aimed to validate a modified version of the raw NASA-TLX in patient monitoring tasks by investigating its correspondence with expected lower and higher workload situations and its robustness against nonworkload-related covariates. This defines criterion validity. METHODS In this pooled analysis, we evaluated raw NASA-TLX scores collected after performing patient monitoring tasks in four different investigator-initiated, computer-based, prospective, multicenter studies. All of them were conducted in three hospitals with a high standard of care in central Europe. In these already published studies, we compared conventional patient monitoring with two newly developed situation awareness–oriented monitoring technologies called Visual Patient and Visual Clot. The participants were resident and staff anesthesia and intensive care physicians, and nurse anesthetists with completed specialization qualification. We analyzed the raw NASA-TLX scores by fitting mixed linear regression models and univariate models with different covariates. RESULTS We assessed a total of 1160 raw NASA-TLX questionnaires after performing specific patient monitoring tasks. Good test performance and higher self-rated diagnostic confidence correlated significantly with lower raw NASA-TLX scores and the subscores (all P <.001). Staff physicians rated significantly lower workload scores than residents ( P =.001), whereas nurse anesthetists did not show any difference in the same comparison ( P =.83). Standardized distraction resulted in higher rated total raw NASA-TLX scores ( P <.001) and subscores. There was no gender difference regarding perceived workload ( P =.26). The new visualization technologies Visual Patient and Visual Clot resulted in significantly lower total raw NASA-TLX scores and all subscores, including high self-rated performance, when compared with conventional monitoring (all P <.001). CONCLUSIONS This study validated a modified raw NASA-TLX questionnaire for patient monitoring tasks. The scores obtained correctly represented the assumed influences of the examined covariates on the perceived workload. We reported high criterion validity. The NASA-TLX questionnaire appears to be a reliable tool for measuring subjective workload. Further research should focus on its applicability in a clinical setting.

A Mental Workload Study on the 2d and 3d Viewing Conditions of the da Vinci Surgical Robot

Physiological Metrics of Surgical Difficulty and Multi-Task Requirement during Robotic Surgery Skills

Identification of Cognitive Workload during Surgical Tasks with Multimodal Deep Learning

Assessment of Surgeons' Stress Levels with Digital Sensors during Robot-Assisted Surgery: An Experimental Study

Anthropometric Assessment of the da Vinci Surgical Robot

Comparison of cognitive workload and surgical outcomes between a three-dimensional and conventional microscope macular hole surgery

Continuous Monitoring of Mental Load During Virtual Simulator Training for Laparoscopic Surgery Reflects Laparoscopic Dexterity: A Comparative Study Using a Novel Wireless Device

Comparative Study on 2D and 3D User Interface for Eliminating Cognitive Loads in Augmented Reality Repetitive Tasks

Multimodal Physiological Signals for Workload Prediction in Robot-assisted Surgery

Study on Mental Workload in Manipulator Teleoperation Mission

Validation of the Raw National Aeronautics and Space Administration Task Load Index (NASA-TLX) Questionnaire to Assess Perceived Workload in Patient Monitoring Tasks: Pooled Analysis Study Using Mixed Models (Preprint)

3D monitors improve performance on the HUGO™ RAS system: a randomised trial

Intraoperative teamwork and occupational stress during robot-assisted surgery: An observational study

Using Eye-Movement Events to Determine the Mental Workload of Surgical Residents

Investigation of Multiple Resource Theory Design Principles on Robot Teleoperation and Workload Management

Continuous monitoring of cognitive load using advanced computerized analysis of brain signals during virtual simulator training for laparoscopic surgery, reflects laparoscopic dexterity. A comparative study using a novel wireless device

Development of an Interactive Dashboard to Analyze Cognitive Workload of Surgical Teams During Complex Procedural Care

Eye Tracking for Tele-robotic Surgery: A Comparative Evaluation of Head-worn Solutions

Investigating mental workload across task modalities: a multimodal analysis using pupillometry

Study on Situation Awareness under Different Mental Workloads

Eye-Tracking for Performance Evaluation and Workload Estimation in Space Telerobotic Training