Abstract:The present paper aims to contribute to the ongoing scholarly discussion about the impact of Western concepts on the modern East Asian understanding of Buddhism. Previous studies on the intellectual and cultural history of Chinese Buddhism in China’s Republican (1911–1949) period suggest that the newly imported distinctions between religion and philosophy, and reason and faith, were instrumental in creating a new secular discourse that favoured the doctrinally orientated Buddhist traditions (notably Consciousness-only/Yogācāra) and belittled the more practical and devotional Buddhist currents (especially Pure Land Buddhism). While those observations pertain to the views of secular elites, a much more complex picture emerges from the confessional literature of the Republican period, for example Buddhist journals. As the present paper demonstrates, while some followers of the movement of ‘Consciousness-only studies’ were indeed critical of Pure Land devotionalism, they did not necessarily problematise it by appealing to the newly introduced Western conceptual framework.The first part of the present paper reexamines the devotional model of Pure Land practice associated with the influential Republican-era monk Yinguang. It argues that Yinguang’s lukewarm attitude towards intellectual approach to Buddhism was itself based in his particular interpretation of traditional Buddhist thought – especially the scholastic distinction between ‘principle’ and ‘phenomena’, and the Sinitic Buddha-Nature thought, which prioritises practical and non-conceptual wisdom over discursive knowledge. In the second part the paper turns to the critique of popular Pure Land piety undertaken by the lay Consciousness-only scholar Tang Dayuan, who opted for including doctrinal study in the practice of Pure Land Buddhism. Whereas Tang’s arguments for this case refer to the increasingly globalised and Westernised intellectual scene of Republican China, his reformist postulates mainly target the aforementioned exegetical and doctrinal assumptions that were shared by Yinguang and other Pure Land preachers. For example, Tang appears to sideline the dichotomy of principle (insight) and phenomena (practice) and opts instead for a unified standard of Pure Land practice grounded in doctrinal understanding. At the same time, he adduces Consciousness-only scholasticism to argue for a broader and more nuanced understanding of Buddhist wisdom, which includes discursive and communicable knowledge. In these respects Tang’s critique reveals a continuity between late imperial and modern Buddhist thought, both in terms of underlying concerns and the concepts that were used to articulate them.

Heterotopia and the Southern Heaven: Xingyun’s Antipodean Buddhist Mission

Tourists and Buddhist Heritage Sites: an Integrative Analysis of Visitors' Experience and Happiness Through Positive Psychology Constructs

Buddhism Co. Ltd? Epistemology of religiosity, and the re-invention of a Buddhist monastery in Hong Kong

A Tale of Two Parks: Tibetan Youths' Preferences for Tourism Community Futures

A heterotopic reading of heritage: The Village of Our Lady in Ka Ho, Macau

'FEMINIST' BUDDHISM AND WOMEN EMPOWERMENT FROM A CONTEMPORARY CHINESE PERSPECTIVE

Converted to Buddhism or Longing for an Idyllic Imaginary Life? Conflict and Fantasy Liberation under Employment Pressure in China

Buddhism, an Urban Village and Cultural Soft Power: An Ethnography of Buddhist Practitioners in Wutong

Origin, development and evolution: the space construction and cultural motivations of Shi Gandang temple in Macau

Comparison between Feng-shui and Landscape Ecology Benefit of the Buddhist Temple Garden of Tiantai Stream:A Case Study of the Guangshan Jingju Temple and Tiantai Guoqing Temple

Practice and Understanding in Modern Chinese Pure Land Buddhism

Big Buddhas, pilgrims and pagodas: an examination of the social geography of Buddhist sites in Rongxian, southern Sichuan

Who Owns Religion? Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Cultural Appropriation in Postglobal Buddhism

Spatiotemporal topology of religious spread in a multi‐religious metropolis: A historical religious profile of Taipei City in Taiwan from 1660 to 2020

Sasaki Gesshō’s Reading of the Huayan Sūtra

An Unexpected Opportunity

Chinese Thought and Transcendentalism: Ecology, Place and Conservative Radicalism

Wudang Mountain and Mount Zion in Taiwan: Syncretic Processes in Space, Ritual Performance, and Imagination

Two Buddhisms in Contemporary Mongolia

Temples as centres of communal networks: a case study of South Lantau

Visitors' perceptions of religious tourism destinations