A Review of Empirical Literature on Inquiry Professional Development: Alignment with Best Practices and a Critique of the Findings

Daniel K. Capps,Barbara A. Crawford,Mark A. Constas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10972-012-9275-2

2012-03-29

Journal of Science Teacher Education

Abstract:This review brings together the literature on inquiry-based teaching and learning and science teacher professional development (PD). We present a targeted critical review of research focused specifically on the nature of PD programs purported to emphasize inquiry. Our review analyzes the features of each program and critiques the reported outcomes of each study. Findings from this review suggest a general alignment with recommended features of effective PD as outlined in the literature with a few notable exceptions, including: supporting teachers in developing inquiry-based lesson plans, providing authentic inquiry experiences, and focusing on science content for teachers. More importantly, our review reveals that no reported study has connected participation in inquiry-based PD with all the desired outcomes of teacher PD: enhanced teacher knowledge, change in beliefs and practice, and enhanced student achievement. Implications for future research on inquiry-based PD programs are discussed.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:

1. **The relationship between inquiry - based teaching and teacher professional development**: The paper aims to explore the connection between inquiry - based teaching and teacher professional development (PD), especially those teacher professional development programs that emphasize inquiry - based teaching methods.

2. **Comprehensive evaluation of existing research**: The paper conducts a critical review and evaluation of the existing empirical literature on professional development programs for inquiry - based teaching, in order to understand the design features of these programs and their reported research results.

3. **Effectiveness of program design**: The paper analyzes whether these programs meet the key characteristics of effective teacher professional development, such as providing sufficient total time, continuous support, authentic inquiry experiences, consistency with standards, curriculum development, demonstration of inquiry, reflection, transfer, and enhancement of content knowledge.

4. **Robustness of research results**: The paper also evaluates the robustness of each research result, especially the findings of these studies in enhancing teacher knowledge, changing teacher beliefs and practices, and improving student academic performance.

5. **The effects after teachers participate in inquiry - based professional development**: The paper pays special attention to whether there are research reports that can link teachers' participation in inquiry - based professional development with all the desired teacher professional development outcomes (such as the enhancement of teacher knowledge, the change of beliefs and practices, and the improvement of student academic achievement).

Through the discussion of these issues, the author hopes to reveal the current situation of current inquiry - based teaching professional development programs and provide guidance and suggestions for future related research.