Abstract:Thermal comfort modeling based on average response of occupants has been of interest in building performance assessment for many years. Energy consumption optimization was the main concern initially, but recently, it was shown that poor health was significantly associated with thermal discomfort. It is crucial to control hospitals' thermal comfort requirements, particularly when the patient and the caregiver have to stay in the same room for a long time. These goals may be obtained if personal comfort models, that predict individuals' comfort responses, are considered instead. The primary goal in this study was to investigate the effects of physiological and environmental factors on individuals' thermal preferences in indoor environments using datasets collected for the Green Buildings Innovation Cluster (GBIC) project. Hence, several feature sets were created considering various combinations of the physiological, environmental and personal factors and several machine learning classification algorithms were utilized to develop personal comfort models, including Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Machine (SVM), K-Nearest Neighbor (KNN) and an ensemble algorithm in two different approaches: multi classification and binary classification. Models' Performances were evaluated and compared employing several metrics. The median accuracies of 0.89 and 0.84 were obtained considering the models with the best performances on the cross-validation sets in multi-classification and binary classification approaches, respectively. Furthermore, more complex models such as RF and SVM predicted individuals' thermal preferences more precisely yet required more computational time than other classifiers. The results in this study indicated that skin temperature is a strong predictor of personal thermal preferences and a combination of several physiological parameters, including metabolic rate and heart rate, with the skin temperature data as inputs for the models would provide higher predicting accuracies.

A systematic review of personal thermal comfort models

A systematic review of research on personal thermal comfort using infrared technology

Thermal comfort models and their developments: A review

Personal thermal comfort models: a deep learning approach for predicting older people’s thermal preference

Personal thermal comfort models based on physiological measurements – A design of experiments based review

Evolution and performance analysis of adaptive thermal comfort models – A comprehensive literature review

Personal comfort models based on a 6‐month experiment using environmental parameters and data from wearables

Comparison among different modeling approaches for personal comfort prediction when using personal comfort systems

Individual Difference in Thermal Comfort: A Literature Review

Comparison among Different Modeling Approaches for Personalized Thermal Comfort Prediction when Using Personal Comfort Systems

Application of machine learning in thermal comfort studies: A review of methods, performance and challenges

Thermal comfort and energy performance of personal comfort systems (PCS): a systematic review and meta-analysis

A review of human thermal comfort model in predicting human-environment interaction in non-uniform environmental conditions

Evaluation of thermal comfort and heat stress indices in different countries and regions – A Review

Human metabolic rate and thermal comfort in buildings: The problem and challenge

Machine-learning-based personal thermal comfort modeling for heat recovery using environmental parameters

Progress in Thermal Comfort Research over the Last Twenty Years

A systematic review of Personal Comfort Systems from a post-phenomenological view

Subjective information in thermal comfort evaluation methods: A critical review

Development of a Health Data-Driven Model for a Thermal Comfort Study

Human thermal comfort model and evaluation on building thermal environment