Valerie J. Callanan
Abstract:This study compares the impact of multiple forms of crime-related media across white, Latino, and African American respondents on their perception of crime risk in their neighborhoods and fear of crime, using a state-wide survey of 3,712 Californians. The findings indicate some difference in the impact of crime-related media by different media forms and across race/ethnic groups. Consumption of local television news significantly elevated perceptions of risk and fear of crime for all groups. Crime-based reality programs produced equivalent fear, but the effects of newspaper and crime drama consumption were more variable. Realistic television content about crime was most influential on viewers' perceptions of and responses to crime than fictional accounts or newspapers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore whether there are differences in the impact of crime - related media on the perceived crime risk and fear of crime among different racial/ethnic groups (whites, Latinos, and African - Americans). Specifically, the study aims to answer two main questions:
1. How do different types of crime - related media influence people's fear of crime?
2. Does the influence of the media on the fear of crime vary by race/ethnicity?
### Research Background and Motivation
The study points out that a large number of studies have shown that violent content in the mass media will increase the public's fear of criminal victimization. Since most Americans obtain crime information through the mass media rather than personal experiences, the frequent presentation of random violent events by the media is considered to increase the salience of crime in people's lives, raise their risk assessment, and make them more afraid of crime. However, most of the research on the relationship between media consumption and the fear of crime has focused on the general population, and few studies have specifically examined the differences in this relationship among different racial/ethnic groups.
### Research Hypotheses
1. **Resonance Hypothesis**: When media messages match the experiences and reality of the audience, their effects are stronger. Therefore, residents living in high - crime - rate areas, especially those who already have a high fear of crime, may become more afraid after watching crime - related media.
2. **Substitution Hypothesis**: For those with little or no relevant experience, the media's effects are stronger. For example, among groups with a lower crime victimization rate such as the elderly, the wealthy, and whites, as media consumption increases, their fear of crime may be higher than that of young people, the poor, and people of color.
### Research Methods
The study used data from a statewide probability sampling survey conducted in California from March to September 1999. The survey adopted the methods of random - digit dialing and computer - assisted telephone interviews, and a total of 4,245 valid questionnaires were collected, with a response rate of 69.9%. The analysis sample included 2,500 whites, 111 Latinos, and 435 African - Americans.
### Main Variables
- **Dependent Variable**: Fear of crime, measured by asking respondents about their fear levels of eight criminal behaviors (0 - 10 points).
- **Intermediate Variable**: Perception of community crime risk, measured by asking respondents about the likelihood of seven criminal behaviors occurring in the community (0 - 10 points).
- **Independent Variable**: Consumption frequencies of four crime - related media, including newspapers, local TV news, TV crime reality shows, and TV crime dramas.
### Research Findings
Preliminary results show that there are significant differences among different racial/ethnic groups in the types and amounts of crime - related media consumption. Overall, the consumption of local TV news significantly increases all groups' perception of crime risk and fear of crime. Crime reality shows generate a comparable level of fear, but the consumption effects of newspapers and crime dramas are more variable.
### Conclusions
By comparing the reactions of different racial/ethnic groups after consuming crime - related media, this study reveals that the influence of the media on the fear of crime varies among different groups. These findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the role of the media in shaping the public's cognitive and emotional responses to crime, especially in different sociocultural contexts.