Abstract:Congruence hypotheses play a major role in many areas of psychology. They refer to, for example, the consequences of person-environment fit, similarity, or self-other agreement. For example, are people psychologically better adjusted when their self-view is in line with their reputation? A valid statistical approach that can be applied to investigate congruence hypotheses of this kind is quadratic Response Surface Analysis (RSA) in which a second-order polynomial model is fit to the data and appropriately interpreted. However, quadratic RSA does not allow researchers to investigate more precise expectations about a congruence effect. Do the data support an asymmetric congruence effect, in the sense that congruence leads to the highest (or lowest) outcome, but incongruence in one direction (e.g., self-view exceeds reputation) affects the outcome differently than incongruence in the other direction (e.g., self-view falls behind reputation)? Is there a level-dependent congruence effect, such that the amount of congruence is more strongly related to the outcome variable for some levels of the predictors (e.g., high self-view and reputation) than for others (e.g., low self-view and reputation)? Such complex congruence hypotheses have frequently been suggested in the literature, but they could not be investigated because an appropriate statistical approach has yet to be developed. Here, we present analytical strategies, based on third-order polynomial models, that enable users to investigate asymmetric and level-dependent congruence effects, respectively. To facilitate the correct application of the suggested approaches, we provide respective step-by-step guidelines, corresponding R syntax, and illustrative analyses using simulated and real data. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved)

Which Response Surface Design is Best: A Performance Comparison of Several Types of Quadratic Response Surface Designs in Symmetric Regions

Gradient-Based Response Surface Approximations for Design Optimization

Adjoint-Response Surface Method in Aerodynamic Shape Optimization of Turbomachinery Blades

An Adaptive Interpolating MLS Based Response Surface Model Applied to Design Optimizations of Electromagnetic Devices

Aerodynamic Shape Optimization of a Transonic Fan by an Adjoint-Response Surface Method

A Response Surface Methodology Based On Improved Compactly Supported Radial Basis Function And Its Application To Rapid Optimizations Of Electromagnetic Devices

$E$-optimal designs for second-order response surface models

Optimal response surface designs in the presence of model contamination

Appropriate Number of Center Points for Response Surface Exploration Using Small Box Behnken Design

An Adaptive Optimal Strategy Based on the Combination of the Dynamic-Q Optimization Method and Response Surface Methodology

Second-order Reliability Alogorithm and Its Applications Using Response Surface Method

A Fast Global Optimal Technique Based On Combinations Of Improved Radial Basis Functions And Tabu Search Method

Sequential Design for Ranking Response Surfaces

Construction of twenty-six points specific optimum second order rotatable designs in three dimensions with a practical example

New approaches on composite designs for Response Surface Methodology

Multiobjective Optimization Based on Response Surface Model and Its Application to Engineering Shape Design

Response Surface Modeling by Local Kernel Partial Least Squares.

Modeling Multiresponse Surfaces for Airfoil Design with Multiple-Output-Gaussian-Process Regression

An improved response surface model and its applications in the fast and global optimizations of electromagnetic devices

A Fast Global Optimizer Based on Improved CS-RBF and Stochastic Optimal Algorithm

Cubic response surface analysis: Investigating asymmetric and level-dependent congruence effects with third-order polynomial models.