Abstract:Abstract Background The growing population of students that are learning science through a Content and Language Integrated Learning approach (CLIL) has led to concerns about these students’ ability to fully participate in a rich classroom discourse to develop content knowledge. A lack of information about science development through classroom discourse in CLIL settings brought us to focus on the questions teachers ask in upper secondary CLIL biology classrooms. Our aim was to understand how these questions effect science content learning opportunities. A multiple-case study design was implemented to examine and understand the complexities of teacher-student interactions. Data were collected in three case studies, each located in a different school (two in Germany and one in Italy), where CLIL senior secondary science classrooms were observed and audio-recorded. Classroom talk transcripts were analyzed using a mixed methods approach to discourse analysis. Results Findings suggest that a teacher’s strategic use of questions has the potential to promote both science understanding and science language development. Questioning contingent on students’ answers was observed to both promote content understanding and to lessen the linguistic demand on CLIL students by splitting both reasoning processes and language production into more manageable units. In addition, a higher level of cognitive engagement was present only when students managed to participate in the classroom discourse with answers longer than single utterances. To allow students to actively participate in the classroom discourse, teachers were observed adopting and promoting translanguaging practices, that is, the flexible use of more than one linguistic code. Furthermore, teachers asked language-related questions that promoted both understanding and use of disciplinary language. Conclusions The questioning practices observed in this study offer both practitioners and researchers ways of understanding issues of content access in upper secondary CLIL science classrooms. We recommend STEM teachers in CLIL settings not to oversimplify the linguistic demand on students, as this leads to an oversimplification of content. To lessen the linguistic barriers, practical strategies are recommended to support both cognitively and linguistically productive questioning in STEM CLIL classrooms.

Interactions Between Classroom Discourse, Teacher Questioning, and Student Cognitive Engagement in Middle School Science

Classroom Interaction in Science: Teacher questioning and feedback to students’ responses

Investigating discursive functions and potential cognitive demands of teacher questioning in the science classroom

Relationships Between Teacher Discursive Moves and Middle School Students’ Cognitive Contributions to Science Concepts

Building science through questions in Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) classrooms

Analyzing the Differences of Interaction and Engagement in a Smart Classroom and a Traditional Classroom

Investigating Student-Generated Questioning in a Technology-Enabled Elementary Science Classroom: A Case Study

The Analysis of Classroom Discourse: Elementary School Science Curricula Advancing Reasoning With Evidence

Classroom Environments and Middle School Students' Views of Science

Analyzing the Patterns of Questioning Chains and Their Intervention on Student Learning in Science Teacher Preparation

Experiential Learning in Upper Elementary Science Classrooms: Influence on Students’ Problem-Solving and Affect in Science

Teacher beliefs, classroom process quality, and student engagement in the smart classroom learning environment: A multilevel analysis

Development of Two-Dimensional Classroom Discourse Analysis Tool (CDAT): scientific reasoning and dialog patterns in the secondary science classes

Characterizing engagement in the science practices: A study of preservice elementary teachers

Discourse forms in a classroom transitioning to student-centred scientific inquiry through co-teaching

Teacher questions, wait time, and student output in classroom interaction in EMI science classes: An interdisciplinary view

Teaching questioning fosters adolescent curiosity: Analyzing impact through multiple-group structural equation modeling

Observational study of student engagement and its relationship to design elements of remote discussion sections

Exploration and Analysis of Middle School Teachers' Classroom Questioning Methods from the Perspective of Dialogue Education

Can Digital Technology Bridge the Classroom Engagement Gap? Findings from a Qualitative Study of K-8 Classrooms in 10 Ontario School Boards

Interest in Dialogic and Non-Dialogic Teacher Talk Situations in Middle School Science Classroom