Mind the Map: Redesigning the London Underground Map
Kenneth Field Esri Inc.,Redlands,CA,USAKen is a permanently recovering academic from the UK with a Bachelors in cartography and PhD in GIS. He grew tired of admin,and ditched his 20 year academic career,moved to the US,and talks and writes about cartography,teaches,and makes maps at Esri in California. He has presented and published an awful lot. He blogs (cartoblography.com),tweets (kennethfield),after eight years as Chair is now Vice-Chair of the ICA Map Design Commission,and did a nine-year stint as Editor of The Cartographic Journal,He's won a few awards for maps,teaching cartography,kitchen tile designs and his books 'Cartography.' and 'Thematic Mapping'. He teaches a MOOC on cartography which has had nearly 200,000 participants to date,and is co-founder of the popular mappery.org site. He snowboards (reasonably),plays drums (badly) and is a long-suffering supporter of his home-town football team Nottingham Forest. Maps are his passion,and profession.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00087041.2024.2366574
2024-08-30
The Cartographic Journal
Abstract:In May 2022, ahead of the 90th anniversary of Beck's original London Underground map, Transport for London opened the new Elizabeth Line, and added it to the already-congested map. But is the map still fit for purpose? This paper references critiques of the recent iterations of the map, and undertakes a cartographic review that assesses its form and function. It includes new designs of the map, created by the author, that attempt to deal with the issues identified, as well as providing a wider critique. In exploring why cartographers and designers offer alternative, often unrequested, new designs of such classic maps, the paper will reflect upon the issue of whether holding on to an iconic map, with its flaws, is preferable to letting go of the past and designing a completely new map. Changing the map would be a brave move, but is one that this author, among others, feels is too pertinent an issue to continue to ignore.
geography