Abstract:BackgroundAccurate estimation of parameters of biochemical models is required to characterize the dynamics of molecular processes. This problem is intimately linked to identifying the most informative experiments for accomplishing such tasks. While significant progress has been made, effective experimental strategies for parameter identification and for distinguishing among alternative network topologies remain unclear. We approached these questions in an unbiased manner using a unique community-based approach in the context of the DREAM initiative (Dialogue for Reverse Engineering Assessment of Methods). We created an in silico test framework under which participants could probe a network with hidden parameters by requesting a range of experimental assays; results of these experiments were simulated according to a model of network dynamics only partially revealed to participants.ResultsWe proposed two challenges; in the first, participants were given the topology and underlying biochemical structure of a 9-gene regulatory network and were asked to determine its parameter values. In the second challenge, participants were given an incomplete topology with 11 genes and asked to find three missing links in the model. In both challenges, a budget was provided to buy experimental data generated in silico with the model and mimicking the features of different common experimental techniques, such as microarrays and fluorescence microscopy. Data could be bought at any stage, allowing participants to implement an iterative loop of experiments and computation.ConclusionsA total of 19 teams participated in this competition. The results suggest that the combination of state-of-the-art parameter estimation and a varied set of experimental methods using a few datasets, mostly fluorescence imaging data, can accurately determine parameters of biochemical models of gene regulation. However, the task is considerably more difficult if the gene network topology is not completely defined, as in challenge 2. Importantly, we found that aggregating independent parameter predictions and network topology across submissions creates a solution that can be better than the one from the best-performing submission.

Wisdom of crowds for robust gene network inference

Gene regulatory network reconstruction using Bayesian networks, the Dantzig Selector, the Lasso and their meta-analysis

Large Scale Gene Regulatory Network Inference with a Multi-Level Strategy.

Gene Regulatory Network Inference from Multifactorial Perturbation Data Using Both Regression and Correlation Analyses

Reverse Engineering Of Gene Regulation Networks With An Application To The Dream4 In Silico Network Challenge

A computational framework for gene regulatory network inference that combines multiple methods and datasets

Gene regulatory network inference and validation using relative change ratio analysis and time-delayed dynamic Bayesian network

Performance and Improvement of Tree-Based Methods for Gene Regulatory Network Reconstruction

NIMEFI: Gene Regulatory Network Inference using Multiple Ensemble Feature Importance Algorithms

Reconstruction of Gene Regulatory Networks usingMultiple Datasets

Gene Regulatory Network Inference from Multifactorial Perturbation Data

Supervised, semi-supervised and unsupervised inference of gene regulatory networks

Gene Regulatory Network Inference Methodology for Genomic and Transcriptomic Data Acquired in Genetically Related Heterozygote Individuals

Gene regulation network inference using k-nearest neighbor-based mutual information estimation: revisiting an old DREAM

Topology Estimation of Gene Regulatory Networks with Relative Expression Level Variations

Evaluation and optimization of sequence-based gene regulatory deep learning models

A Relative Variation-Based Method To Unraveling Gene Regulatory Networks

Multi-Species Network Inference Improves Gene Regulatory Network Reconstruction for Early Embryonic Development in Drosophila

A community effort to optimize sequence-based deep learning models of gene regulation

Network topology and parameter estimation: from experimental design methods to gene regulatory network kinetics using a community based approach

A Novel Computational Framework to Reconstruct Gene Regulatory Networks from Gene Sets