Professional Development That Works: Shifting Preschool Teachers' Beliefs and Use of Instructional Strategies to Promote Children's Peer Social Competence

Heejeong Sophia Han
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10901027.2012.705804
2012-07-01
Journal of Early Childhood Teacher Education
Abstract:This study examined the effectiveness of a professional development (PD) experience on preschool teachers' instructional strategy development. Focusing on supporting young children's peer social competence as a common interest, preschool teachers were guided to design the specific contents of the PD workshops and were offered an on-site facilitation opportunity, delineating teacher-driven and job-embedded approaches, respectively. Findings from this study suggest that teacher-driven PD workshops significantly increased teachers' perceived feasibility of implementing instructional strategies, and their actual use of those strategies was significantly influenced by job-embedded facilitations. In addition, preschool teachers considered physical classroom environment and children's language to be the most challenging factors in their instructional strategy implementation. Implications and directions for an effective PD model for preschool teachers are discussed.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: to improve the effectiveness of preschool education teachers' beliefs in supporting the development of young children's peer social skills and teaching strategies through professional development (PD). Specifically, the research focuses on the following points: 1. **What are the main concerns and information needs of preschool teachers in supporting the development of young children's peer social skills?** 2. **How much influence do teacher - led workshops have on preschool teachers' beliefs in teaching strategies for supporting young children's peer social skills?** 3. **How much influence does work - based embedded coaching have on preschool teachers' beliefs in teaching strategies for supporting young children's peer social skills?** 4. **What is the relationship between preschool teachers' acceptance, feasibility, and current use of teaching strategies for supporting young children's peer social skills?** ### Research Background - **Professional Development (PD)**: The traditional "sit - and - listen" professional development model is considered ineffective, so new PD models are needed. These models place more emphasis on teachers' practical knowledge (knowledge in practice) and reflective practice. - **Peer Social Skills**: Young children's peer social skills are crucial for their future school adaptation and social success. Although many strategies have been proposed, preschool education teachers still face challenges in practical application. - **Teacher Beliefs**: Teachers' personal beliefs have an important influence on their teaching practice. Effective PD should not only change teachers' behaviors but also their fundamental beliefs. ### Research Methods - **Participants**: Fourteen female teachers from four different kindergartens participated in the study, with their teaching experience ranging from 1 year to 22 years, with an average of 8.6 years. - **Procedures**: - **Initial Focus Group**: Understand teachers' needs and concerns through focus group meetings. - **Teacher - led Workshops**: Five workshop themes were designed according to teachers' needs and arranged in the order of the pyramid model. - **Work - based Embedded Coaching**: Researchers visited each teacher's classroom monthly to provide personalized feedback and support. - **Final Focus Group**: At the end of the project, teachers got together again to discuss their experiences and evaluate the effectiveness of the project. ### Research Findings - **Teacher - led workshops significantly improved teachers' perception of the feasibility of implementing teaching strategies, and the actual use of these strategies was also significantly influenced by work - based embedded coaching.** - **Teachers believe that the physical environment of the classroom and children's language ability are the biggest challenges in implementing teaching strategies.** ### Conclusions and Recommendations - **Effective PD Model**: The research suggests that an effective PD model should include teacher - driven workshops and work - based embedded coaching to promote teachers' continuous learning and practical improvement. - **Future Research Directions**: Further research is needed on how to better support teachers in applying new teaching strategies in actual teaching, especially in the case of limited resources.