Abstract:Systematic assignment of fossil otoliths is virtually always based on studies of otolith morphology and subsequent comparisons with otoliths from collections and/or literature. Although this usually represents a practical method, comparisons and subsequent evaluation may be biased by subjective criteria used in the individual descriptions. Quantitative morphometric studies focusing on variations in the otolith morphology of extant fishes have been conducted in fisheries research, mostly based on Fourier shape analysis and related methods. However, with regard to fossil otoliths, these approaches are generally not suitable, mainly due to preservation-related problems. Here we present a new approach for quantifying otolith variation between species and populations of killifish (cyprinodontiforms) in the genera Aphanius Nardo and daggerProlebias Sauvage that can be used with both extant and fossil otoliths. Our new approach includes the definition of 10 variables from linear and angle measurements of an otolith and statistical analyses. Best results were obtained by presorting the otoliths into three groups based on sulcus shape (straight, bent, S-shaped). In this case, canonical discriminant analysis (CDA) with jackknifed cross-validation yielded an overall species classification success of 86-96%. The three groups based on sulcus shape separate according to zoogeographic patterns (i.e., Mediterranean Aphanius, Arabian Aphanius, European daggerProlebias) and probably reflect phylogenetic lineages. Application of CDA to compare otolith variation between populations resulted in an overall classification success (jackknifed) of 33-83%. High levels of variation were observed for Aphanius dispar and daggerProlebias malzi, but not for A. fasciatus and daggerP. weileri. We suggest that otolith variation between populations results predominantly from geographic separation. Combination of qualitative characters (sulcus morphology) with quantitative approaches (otolith morphometry) presents a new approach for obtaining a better understanding of the taxonomy, diversity, and zoogeography of both fossil and extant killifishes. Moreover, the method may also be suitable for assessing taxonomy and diversity in other species-rich groups like the atheriniforms and many perciforms because these groups display otolith Bauplans that are similar to those seen in killifishes.

Otolith and vertebral morphology of marine atherinid species (Atheriniformes, Atherinopsidae) coexisting in the southwestern Atlantic Ocean

Otolith Morphology and Relationships of Several Fish Species of the Suborder Scorpaenoidei

Allometric changes and shape differentiation of sagitta otoliths in sciaenid fishes

Atlas of marine bony fish otoliths (sagittae) of Southeastern-Southern Brazil Part VII: Atheriniformes, Beloniformes, Beryciformes, Zeiformes, Syngnathiformes, Scorpaeniformes and Tetraodontiformes

Variability of Otolith Morphology and Morphometry in Eight Juvenile Fish Species in the Coastal Eastern Adriatic

Characteristics of sagittae morphology in sixteen marine fish species collected from the Persian Gulf: Demonstration of the phylogenetic influence on otolith shape

The multifaceted diversification of the sagitta otolith across the fish tree of life

Interspecific and intersexual variability of the sagitta otolith shape between Liza aurata and Chelon ramada (Mugiliformes: Mugilidae) inhabiting the Boughrara lagoon, Tunisia

Testing otolith morphology for measuring marine fish biodiversity

Otolith shape variability of labrid fish from Rapa Nui (Easter Island), southeastern Pacific

An anomalous otolith of Engraulis australis (Clupeiformes, Engraulidae) from the food of the Australasian gannet Morus serrator, New Zealand

Combined otolith morphology and morphometry for assessing taxonomy and diversity in fossil and extant killifish (Aphanius, †Prolebias)

All Good Things Come In Threes - Species Delimitation Through Shape Analysis Of Saccular, Lagenar And Utricular Otoliths (Vol 63, Pg 934, 2012)

Morphologic Characters of the Sagittal Otoliths of Fishes of the Genus Epinephelus in the China Sea

Morphologic, morphometric and contour shape variations of sagittal otoliths of Lepidorhombus spp. in the Aegean Sea

Otolith shape and isotopic ratio analyses as a tool to study Spondyliosoma cantharus population structure

Otolith shape variability and associated body growth differences in giant grenadier, Albatrossia pectoralis

Discriminating Scleromystax barbatus (Siluriformes: Callichthyidae) populations from Atlantic Rainforest streams employing otolith shape

Morphological and morphometric features of the abnormal and normal saccular otoliths in flatfishes

All good things come in threes – species delimitation through shape analysis of saccular, lagenar and utricular otoliths

Discrimination of red porgy Pagrus pagrus (Sparidae) potential stocks in the South-western Atlantic by otolith shape analysis.