Abstract:We address the problem of selecting the common factors that are relevant for forecasting macroeconomic variables. In economic forecasting using diffusion indexes the factors are ordered, according to their importance, in terms of relative variability, and are the same for each variable to predict, i.e. the process of selecting the factors is not supervised by the predictand. We propose a simple and operational supervised method, based on selecting the factors on the basis of their significance in the regression of the predictand on the predictors. Given a potentially large number of predictors, we consider linear transformations obtained by principal components analysis. The orthogonality of the components implies that the standard t-statistics for the inclusion of a particular component are independent, and thus applying a selection procedure that takes into account the multiplicity of the hypotheses tests is both correct and computationally feasible. We focus on three main multiple testing procedures: Holm’s sequential method, controlling the family wise error rate, the Benjamini-Hochberg method, controlling the false discovery rate, and a procedure for incorporating prior information on the ordering of the components, based on weighting the p-values according to the eigenvalues associated to the components. We compare the empirical performances of these methods with the classical diffusion index (DI) approach proposed by Stock and Watson, conducting a pseudo-real time forecasting exercise, assessing the predictions of 8 macroeconomic variables using factors extracted from an U.S. dataset consisting of 121 quarterly time series. The overall conclusion is that nature is tricky, but essentially benign: the information that is relevant for prediction is effectively condensed by the first few factors. However, variable selection, leading to exclude some of the low order principal components, can lead to a sizable improvement in forecasting in specific cases. Only in one instance, real personal income, we were able to detect a significant contribution from high order components.

Generalized Shrinkage Methods for Forecasting Using Many Predictors

Forecasting in data-rich environments

Forecasting in Data-Rich Environments: An Application to Inflation Rates

Mining Big Data Using Parsimonious Factor, Machine Learning, Variable Selection and Shrinkage Methods

Forecasting Using Principal Components From a Large Number of Predictors

Shrinking Return Forecasts

Forecasting Accuracy of Sparse Principal Component Analysis in U.S Inflation

Dynamic Shrinkage Processes

Sparse Bayesian Variable Selection in Probit Model for Forecasting U.S. Recessions Using a Large Set of Predictors

Macroeconomic Forecasting and Variable Selection with a Very Large Number of Predictors: A Penalized Regression Approach

On the Selection of Common Factors for Macroeconomic Forecasting

Forecasting Using a Large Number of Predictors: Bayesian Model Averaging Versus Principal Components Regression

Forecasting Global Stock Market Volatilities: A Shrinkage Heterogeneous Autoregressive (HAR) Model with a Large Cross-Market Predictor Set

Solving the Forecast Combination Puzzle Using Double Shrinkages*

Forecasting macroeconomic data with Bayesian VARs: Sparse or dense? It depends!

Variable Selection in Macroeconomic Forecasting with Many Predictors

Dynamic Shrinkage Priors for Large Time-Varying Parameter Regressions Using Scalable Markov Chain Monte Carlo Methods

Factor-based forecasting in the presence of outliers: Are factors better selected and estimated by the median than by the mean?

Shrinkage Estimation of Dynamic Panel Data Models with Interactive Fixed Effects

Forecasting Oil Price Volatility: Forecast Combination Versus Shrinkage Method

Supervised Dynamic PCA: Linear Dynamic Forecasting with Many Predictors