Abstract:Coupled human and natural systems (CHANS) are complex, dynamic, interconnected systems with feedback across social and environmental dimensions. This feedback leads to formidable challenges for causal inference. Two significant challenges involve assumptions about excludability and the absence of interference. These two assumptions have been largely unexplored in the CHANS literature, but when either is violated, causal inferences from observable data are difficult to interpret. To explore their plausibility, structural knowledge of the system is requisite, as is an explicit recognition that most causal variables in CHANS affect a coupled pairing of environmental and human elements. In a large CHANS literature that evaluates marine protected areas, nearly 200 studies attempt to make causal claims, but few address the excludability assumption. To examine the relevance of interference in CHANS, we develop a stylized simulation of a marine CHANS with shocks that can represent policy interventions, ecological disturbances, and technological disasters. Human and capital mobility in CHANS is both a cause of interference, which biases inferences about causal effects, and a moderator of the causal effects themselves. No perfect solutions exist for satisfying excludability and interference assumptions in CHANS. To elucidate causal relationships in CHANS, multiple approaches will be needed for a given causal question, with the aim of identifying sources of bias in each approach and then triangulating on credible inferences. Within CHANS research, and sustainability science more generally, the path to accumulating an evidence base on causal relationships requires skills and knowledge from many disciplines and effective academic-practitioner collaborations.

Detecting Causality in Complex Ecosystems

Temporally or Spatially? Causation Inference in Earth System Sciences.

Spatial Convergent Cross Mapping to Detect Causal Relationships from Short Time Series.

Robust Causality and False Attribution in Data-Driven Earth Science Discoveries

Causal inference from cross-sectional earth system data with geographical convergent cross mapping

Distinguishing Time-Delayed Causal Interactions Using Convergent Cross Mapping

Detecting dynamical causality via intervened reservoir computing

Causal inference in coupled human and natural systems

A Liang-Kleeman Causality Analysis based on Linear Inverse Modeling

Causal discovery from ecological time-series with one timestamp and multiple observations

Partial Cross Mapping Eliminates Indirect Causal Influences

Telling cause from effect in deterministic linear dynamical systems

Detecting Dynamical Causality by Intersection Cardinal Concavity

Causality Reasoning And Discovery For Systems Biology Investigations

Detecting Causality in the Frequency Domain with Cross-Mapping Coherence

Unraveling the Cause-Effect Relation Between Time Series.

Decomposing predictability to identify dominant causal drivers in complex ecosystems

Review on Causality Detection Based on Empirical Dynamic Modeling

The impact of data resolution on dynamic causal inference in multiscale ecological networks

Causality between time series

Modern causal inference approaches to investigate biodiversity-ecosystem functioning relationships