Abstract:Active learning in college classes and participation in the workforce frequently hinge on small group work. However, group dynamics vary, ranging from equitable collaboration to dysfunctional groups dominated by one individual. To explore how group dynamics impact student learning, we asked students in a large-enrollment university biology class to self-report their experience during in-class group work. Specifically, we asked students whether there was a friend in their group, whether they were comfortable in their group, and whether someone dominated their group. Surveys were administered after students participated in two different types of intentionally constructed group activities: 1) a loosely-structured activity wherein students worked together for an entire class period (termed the 'single-group' activity), or 2) a highly-structured 'jigsaw' activity wherein students first independently mastered different subtopics, then formed new groups to peer-teach their respective subtopics. We measured content mastery by the change in score on identical pre-/post-tests. We then investigated whether activity type or student demographics predicted the likelihood of reporting working with a dominator, being comfortable in their group, or working with a friend. We found that students who more strongly agreed that they worked with a dominator were 17.8% less likely to answer an additional question correct on the 8-question post-test. Similarly, when students were comfortable in their group, content mastery increased by 27.5%. Working with a friend was the single biggest predictor of student comfort, although working with a friend did not impact performance. Finally, we found that students were 67% less likely to agree that someone dominated their group during the jigsaw activities than during the single group activities. We conclude that group activities that rely on positive interdependence, and include turn-taking and have explicit prompts for students to explain their reasoning, such as our jigsaw, can help reduce the negative impact of inequitable groups.

Context Matters: Social Psychological Factors That Underlie Academic Performance across Seven Institutions

Contextualizing Learning: A Multi-Variable Analysis of Student Characteristics, Educational Settings, and Academic Success

Context matters: Diagnosing and targeting local barriers to success at school

Contextual Performance in Academic Settings: The Role of Personality, Self-efficacy, and Impression Management

Context Matters: Schools and the “Research to Practice Gap” in Children's Mental Health

Academic performance and behavioral patterns

Context Matters: Differing Implications of Motivation and Help-Seeking in Educational Technology

Broadening Participation in the Life Sciences with Social-Psychological Interventions

Relationship between students’ online learning behavior and course performance: What contextual information matters?

The Impact of School Climate and School Identification on Academic Achievement: Multilevel Modeling with Student and Teacher Data

Student Characteristics, Institutional Factors, and Outcomes in Higher Education and Beyond: An Analysis of Standardized Test Scores and Other Factors at the Institutional Level with School Rankings and Salary

Effects of context on the neural correlates of attention in a college classroom

Student perception of group dynamics predicts individual performance: Comfort and equity matter

The Effects of a Warm or Chilly Climate Toward Socioeconomic Diversity on Academic Motivation and Self-Concept

Introductory Biology in Social Context: The Effects of an Issues-Based Laboratory Course on Biology Student Motivation

Linking engagement and performance: The social network analysis perspective

The Role of Stakeholders Participation, Goal Directness and Learning Context in Determining Student Academic Performance: Student Engagement as a Mediator

Why learning environment matters? An analysis on how the learning environment influences the academic motivation, learning strategies and engagement of college students

Improving the quality of student learning: the influence of learning context and student approaches to learning on learning outcomes

The Social Context of Performance Appraisal: A Review and Framework for the Future