Location selection for hydrogen fuel stations under emerging provider competition

Tobias Crönert,Stefan Minner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trc.2021.103426

2021-12-01

Abstract:Individual hydrogen-based mobility with fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs) is a promising avenue for green house gas reduction in the transportation sector. With a rise in popularity of FCEVs and increased governmental grants and funding, investments in hydrogen refueling stations gain attractiveness for fuel station providers. However, as uncertainty around adoption rates and emerging competition between station providers persists, careful location selection becomes crucial for providers willing to invest in hydrogen fuel stations. We formulate a location problem for hydrogen fuel stations as a competitive flow-capture location–allocation model. In contrast to prior formulations, no prior knowledge of competitor locations is required as we expect competitors to choose locations simultaneously in an emerging competitive environment. We solve the arising competitive model formulation as an integer programming game (IPG). In a real-world scenario, we identify optimal locations for the two largest competing fuel station providers in Munich, Germany. Within this study, providers who acknowledge the existence of their competitor can realize an increase in profit of 17% (averaged across different scenarios of FCEV market penetration & customer preferences). Central coordination (e.g., through conditional subsidies from policymakers) or cooperation between the competitors (e.g., through provider associations) could further increase overall profits by 28%, however this increase in profitability comes at the cost of overall customer travel distance (increased by up to 10% in case of cooperation between providers) as the average detour a customer has to take to refuel increases.

transportation science & technology