Treatment of Mid-Face Aging with Calcium Hydroxylapatite: Focus on Retaining Ligament Support
Mauricio Sato,Mariana Muniz,Luis Ricardo Ferreira
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/ccid.s468447
2024-11-13
Clinical Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology
Abstract:Mauricio Sato, 1 Mariana Muniz, 2 Luis Ricardo Coelho Ferreira 3 1 IDEL Institute, Dermatology Department, Curitiba, Brazil; 2 Mariana Muniz Dermatologia, Dermatology Department, São Paulo, Brazil; 3 Federal University of Parana, Radiology Department, Curitiba, Brazil Correspondence: Mauricio Sato, IDEL Institute, Dermatology Department, Alameda Getúlio Vargas 4474, Curitiba, PR, 80240-041, Brazil, Tel +5541 99977-8475; +55413026-0778, Email The mid-face has been rendered as the cornerstone of facial aesthetic improvement, since treating the mid-face has also beneficial effects on neighboring esthetic units and therefore should be one of the first areas to be assessed. Retaining ligaments (RL) bind soft tissue layers of the face to the underlying facial skeleton. It remains controversial whether RL suffers laxity with aging or if changes in 42 bone and other structures where ligaments are inserted lead to altered mechanical function of the latter. Enhancement of the supportive effect of the ligaments could help restore the soft tissues to their original anatomical positions and achieve a lifting effect. While injectable hyaluronic acid implants have been used to improve ligament support, calcium hydroxylapatite has one of the highest viscoelasticities when compared with other dermal fillers and can induce collagen synthesis, which could provide long-term laxity correction. In this preliminary report of a case series, our goal was to describe the use of calcium hydroxylapatite in different dilutions and combinations for different aging profiles to treat the midface as an alternative for hyaluronic acid injections and to describe the ultrasonographic behavior in the long run. Keywords: rejuvenation, retaining ligaments, calcium hydroxylapatite, hyaluronic acid, soft tissue repositioning, aging pattern It has been conceptualized that the soft tissues of the face are arranged into five basic layers bound by a system of facial retaining ligaments. Retaining ligaments are responsible for binding the soft-tissue layers of the face to the underlying facial skeleton, acting as anchor points, and retaining and stabilizing the skin and superficial fascia (SMAS) to the underlying deep fascia and facial skeleton in defined anatomical locations. 1 The ligamentous structures of the face play an important role in restricting facial mobility in different anatomical regions, dictating the way the tissues yield in response to gravity. The face can be divided into 3 parts, namely upper face: from hairline to glabela; midface from glabella to subnasal and lower face from subnasal to submentalis. 2 Since the mid-face has been rendered as the cornerstone of facial aesthetic improvement and should be one of the first areas to be assessed, as treating the mid-face also has beneficial effects on neighboring aesthetic units. 3 The most relevant ligaments in the mid-face are the orbital-retaining ligament, malar septum (zygomatic-cutaneous ligament; ZCL), and McGregor's patch (zygomatic ligament). 4 ZCL is a true an osteocutaneous septum-like structure osteocutaneous ligament originating from the periosteum of the maxilla and zygoma, traversing the overlying fat compartment and muscle and inserting into the skin of the anteromedial mid-face. 5 It starts at the origin of the levator labii superioris and then extends laterally following the curvature of the inferior bone margin of the zygoma in the form of a crescent 6 and plays an important role in fixing the skin of the face. The latter differs from the masseteric and mandibular ligaments, which are false fascio-SMAS ligaments that fixate the superficial fascia and platysma muscle. 7 It is controversial whether ligaments that tether the facial tissues into the anatomic position suffer laxity with aging 8–10 or if changes to the bone and other structures where ligaments are inserted lead to an altered mechanical function such that a ligament that supports the fat within a compartment (superficial or deep) may fatigue and bulge along its course, leading to the appearance of sagging of the respective fat compartment. 1,11–15 With aging, bone resorption in the anterior and inferior aspects of the maxilla leads to retrusion of the mid-face, which, in addition to working as a true slide for the descent of the mid-face soft tissues, further decreases bone support for the zygomatic cutaneous ligament to maintain its tensile strength. 16,17 Approaches to sagging appearance entail repositioning of descended soft tissues to the anatomical position of the youth. 18 In this setting, enhancement of the supportive effect of the ligaments, in its bone or skin insertion, could help restore the soft tissues to their original a -Abstract Truncated-
dermatology