Abstract:Recent scholarship suggests that immigrant selectivity - the degree to which immigrants differ from non-migrants in their sending countries - can help us understand their labour market outcomes in the receiving country. The selectivity hypothesis rests on three assumptions: first, that immigrants differ from non-migrants in their observed characteristics, such as education; second, that there is an association between such observed selection and (usually) unobserved characteristics, and third that this association drives positive relationships between observed selection and immigrant outcomes. While there is some evidence for a relationship between the degree of immigrants' selectivity and their children's outcomes, a comprehensive assessment of these assumptions for immigrants' own labour market outcomes remains lacking. We use high-quality, nationally representative data for the UK, with large numbers of immigrants from a wide range of different origins and with a rich set of measures of networks, traits and characteristics, as well as economic outcomes, not typically found in surveys of immigrants. This enables us to conduct a comprehensive assessment of the selectivity hypothesis and its assumptions. We find that immigrants to the UK are on average positively selected on educational attainment. However, counter to theoretical assumptions, educational selection has little association with labour market outcomes: it is not or negatively associated with employment; and it is only associated with pay for those with tertiary qualifications and with occupational position for women. We show that the general lack of economic benefits from selection is consistent with an absence of association between educational selectivity and (typically unobserved) mechanisms assumed to link selection and labour market outcomes: social networks, cognitive and non-cognitive skills, and mental and physical health. We contextualise our findings with heterogeneity analysis by migration regime, sending country characteristics, level of absolute education and location of credential.

Social Contacts, Dutch Language Proficiency and Immigrant Economic Performance in the Netherlands: A Longitudinal Study

A Longitudinal Study of Interethnic Contacts in Germany: Estimates from a Multilevel Growth Curve Model

The impact of economic recession on the health of migrant fathers over time: results from the Growing up in Ireland longitudinal study

An unlevel playing field: Immigrant assimilation and welfare utilization

A longitudinal perspective to migrant health: Unpacking the immigrant health paradox in Germany

Immigration and labour market flows

Language distance and labor market integration of migrants: Gendered perspective

Earnings of Immigrants in Sweden, 1978 to 1999

Diversity of Social Network and Labor Market Outcome:A study on how social contacts affect the wage of migrant workers

Settlement intention of migrants in urban China: The effects of labor-market performance, employment status, and social integration

Do immigrants benefit from selection? Migrant educational selectivity and its association with social networks, skills and health

Determinants of welfare benefit use of immigrant groups - longitudinal evidence from Germany

Labour market and income inequalities in the Netherlands, 1977–2022

Country of origin and employment prospects among immigrants: an analysis of south–south and north–south migrants to South Africa

Assimilation or Disassimilation?: the Labour Market Performance of Rural Migrants in Chinese Cities

Immigration and the distribution of income, consumption and wealth in the euro area: implications for economic policies

Employer policies and the immigrant–native earnings gap

The domestic economic impacts of immigration

The effect of citizenship on the long-term earnings of marginalized immigrants: Quasi-experimental evidence from Switzerland

Long-term Neighbourhood Effects on Education, Income and Employment among Adolescents in Oslo

Transnational involvement and social integration