Abstract:The role of different sources and sinks of CH4 in changes in atmospheric methane ([CH4]) concentration during the last 100 000 yr is still not fully understood. In particular, the magnitude of the change in wetland CH4 emissions at the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) relative to the pre-industrial period (PI), as well as during abrupt climatic warming or Dansgaard-Oeschger (D-O) events of the last glacial period, is largely unconstrained. In the present study, we aim to understand the uncertainties related to the parameterization of the wetland CH4 emission models relevant to these time periods by using two wetland models of different complexity (SDGVM and ORCHIDEE). These models have been forced by identical climate fields from low-resolution coupled atmosphere-ocean general circulation model (FAMOUS) simulations of these time periods. Both emission models simulate a large decrease in emissions during LGM in comparison to PI consistent with ice core observations and previous modelling studies. The global reduction is much larger in ORCHIDEE than in SDGVM (respectively -67 and -46 %), and whilst the differences can be partially explained by different model sensitivities to temperature, the major reason for spatial differences between the models is the inclusion of freezing of soil water in ORCHIDEE and the resultant impact on methanogenesis substrate availability in boreal regions. Besides, a sensitivity test performed with ORCHIDEE in which the methanogenesis substrate sensitivity to the precipitations is modified to be more realistic gives a LGM reduction of -36 %. The range of the global LGM decrease is still prone to uncertainty, and here we underline its sensitivity to different process parameterizations. Over the course of an idealized D-O warming, the magnitude of the change in wetland CH4 emissions simulated by the two models at global scale is very similar at around 15 Tg yr(-1), but this is only around 25% of the ice-core measured changes in [CH4]. The two models do show regional differences in emission sensitivity to climate with much larger magnitudes of northern and southern tropical anomalies in ORCHIDEE. However, the simulated northern and southern tropical anomalies partially compensate each other in both models limiting the net flux change. Future work may need to consider the inclusion of more detailed wetland processes (e. g. linked to permafrost or tropical flood-plains), other non-wetland CH4 sources or different patterns of D-O climate change in order to be able to reconcile emission estimates with the ice-core data for rapid CH4 events.

Reduction of the temperature sensitivity of minerotrophic fen methane emissions by simulated glacial atmospheric carbon dioxide starvation

Carbon Dioxide and Methane Flux Response and Recovery From Drought in a Hemiboreal Ombrotrophic Fen

Response of Peatland CO2 and CH4 Fluxes to Experimental Warming and the Carbon Balance

Response of methane emissions from wetlands to the Last Glacial Maximum and an idealized Dansgaard–Oeschger climate event: insights from two models of different complexity

Soil incubation methods lead to large differences in inferred methane production temperature sensitivity

Effects of Water Regimes on Methane Emissions in Peatland and Gley Marsh

Opposing seasonal temperature dependencies of CO2 and CH4 emissions from wetlands

Distinct Microbiomes Underlie Divergent Responses of Methane Emissions from Diverse Wetland soils to Oxygen Shifts

Controls of spatial and temporal variability in CH4 flux in a high arctic fen over three years

Changing climatic controls on the greenhouse gas balance of thermokarst bogs during succession after permafrost thaw

Water table depth and plant species determine the direction and magnitude of methane fluxes in floodplain meadow soils

Cold‐Season Methane Fluxes Simulated by GCP‐CH4 Models

Climate sensitivity of peatland methane emissions mediated by seasonal hydrologic dynamics

Plant roots but not hydrology control microbiome composition and methane flux in temperate fen mesocosms

Mediative Mechanism of Freezing/Thawing on Greenhouse Gas Emissions in an Inland Saline-Alkaline Wetland: a Metagenomic Analysis

Hydrological feedbacks on peatland CH4 emission under warming and elevated CO2: A modeling study

Differences in the temperature dependence of wetland CO2 and CH4 emissions vary with water table depth

Resolving the carbon‐climate feedback potential of wetland CO2 and CH4 fluxes in Alaska

Deep peat warming increases surface methane and carbon dioxide emissions in a black spruce‐dominated ombrotrophic bog

Response of methane emissions to litter input manipulation in a temperate freshwater marsh, Northeast China

Lowering Water Table Reduces Carbon Sink Strength and Carbon Stocks in Northern Peatlands