Can soil acidity and light help to explain tree species effects on forest herb layer performance in post-agricultural forests?

Arno Thomaes,Luc De Keersmaeker,An De Schrijver,Lander Baeten,Kris Vandekerkhove,Gorik Verstraeten,Kris Verheyen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11104-013-1786-x
IF: 4.993
2013-06-09
Plant and Soil
Abstract:AimsTree species affect herb layer species through their effects on soil quality and light regime but their relative importance and interactions are insufficiently known.MethodsPot experiment with soil taken from stands planted with tree species with contrasting effects on soil acidification, two light regimes and six forest perennials.ResultsThe survival or growth of Mercurialis perennis, Lamium galeobdolon, Anemone nemorosa and Primula elatior was lower in the acid Alnus soils than in the less acid Fraxinus soils. By contrast, the acid tolerant Convallaria majalis and Dryopteris dilatata were barely affected by tree species. Light conditions had less impact than soil chemistry and did not compensate for unfavourable soil conditions. Ca and P concentrations increased in plants grown in Fraxinus soils. The Mg and Al shoot/root ratios of respectively one and two of the acid tolerant species was elevated in the most acid soil.ConclusionsTree species effects on forest perennials are mainly explained by increased Al concentrations under acidifying species. Changed plant concentrations and allocation are likely associated to Al antagonism. We found no light compensation for the soil effect on the studied species. However, light alters the plant nutrient concentrations and allocation which may suggest an indirect effect.
plant sciences,soil science,agronomy
What problem does this paper attempt to address?