Abstract:Bioretention systems have become a leading infiltration-based Low Impact Development (LID) practice to reduce urban stormwater runoff volumes and peak flows. Although these systems have performed well in many site-scale field studies, modeling of bioretention systems has received less attention. Additional studies are needed which calibrate various models to field measurements to investigate and optimize the performance of individual LID practices and effectively scale local interventions to the watershed. DRAINMOD-Urban has been successfully applied to bioretention at the site-scale due to its advanced soil–water accounting using the soil–water characteristic curve and its ability to explicitly model underdrains and internal water storage (IWS) zones. At the same time, the U.S. EPA Stormwater Management Model (SWMM) has become one of the most widely used urban drainage models. The latest version, SWMM5, included dedicated LID modules including a routine for bioretention modeling.In this study, DRAINMOD-Urban and the SWMM LID module were compared through detailed analysis of the internal processes of each model as well as through model calibration and output investigation. The objective was to identify the strengths and weaknesses of each model and compare the performance of both models to a single bioretention cell. Both SWMM and DRAINMOD-Urban were evaluated in calibrated and uncalibrated scenarios since urban drainage models often remain uncalibrated for planning scenario analysis. Following calibration, DRAINMOD-Urban was superior for replicating drainage hydrographs (NSE = 0.60) while SWMM produced better overflow hydrographs (NSE = 0.57). Specifically, SWMM often output a maximum drainage rate that caused rectangular drainage hydrographs, but DRAINMOD-Urban was better able to match the shape of measured drainage hydrographs. While the DRAINMOD-Urban model output was in good agreement with measured drainage and overflow event volumes when calibrated (drainage NSE = 0.83, overflow NSE = 0.57–0.66), SWMM was closer to measured volumes even when uncalibrated (drainage NSE = 0.70–0.93, overflow NSE = 0.59–0.81). This study improved existing knowledge of the SWMM LID module by calibrating to field-collected data from a single bioretention cell for the first time in literature. Furthermore, the results of this study indicate an opportunity for model coupling that could combine the strengths and weaknesses of each model and improve bioretention cell modeling.

A Comprehensive Water Quality Model of Boston's Drainage Systems

Coupling Watershed Environmental Model with Optimizing Method to Provide Least Cost Alternatives in Environmental Planning and Management

Water Quality Modeling in Sewer Networks: Review and Future Research Directions

Storm Water Management Model: Performance Review and Gap Analysis.

Analysis of pollutant dispersion patterns in rivers under different rainfall based on an integrated water-land model

Hydrologically Enhanced Distributed Urban Drainage Model and Its Application in Beijing City

Modeling bioretention hydrology: Quantifying the performance of DRAINMOD-Urban and the SWMM LID module

A Three-Dimensional Water Quality Model for Estimating TMDLs in a Blackwater River Estuary, the Lower St. Johns River, FL

Application of a Water Quality Model in the White Cart Water Catchment, Glasgow, UK

Urban Pluvial Flood Modeling by Coupling Raster-Based Two-Dimensional Hydrodynamic Model and SWMM

Urban stormwater forecasting model and drainage optimization based on water environmental capacity

[Development and Application of a Multi-Species Water Quality Model for Water Distribution Systems with EPANET-MSX].

Simulations of low impact development designs using the storm water management model

Land cover based simulation of urban stormwater runoff and pollutant loading

The Importance of In-Stream Hydraulics in River Water Quality Models: Lessons from the Blackstone River

The Application of Storm Water Management Model in Comprehensive Planning of Urban Drainage and Flood Control

Study on Integrated Simulation of Urban Drainage System

Introduction of basic principle and application prospect for SWMM

Integrated urban hydrologic and hydraulic modelling in Chicago, Illinois

Impact and analysis of urban water system connectivity project on regional water environment based on Storm Water Management Model (SWMM)

Robustness analysis of storm water quality modelling with LID infrastructures from natural event-based field monitoring