Abstract:Estimates of functional connectivity derived from resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI) are sensitive to artefacts caused by in-scanner head motion. This susceptibility has motivated the development of numerous denoising methods designed to mitigate motion-related artefacts. Here, we compare popular retrospective rs-fMRI denoising methods, such as regression of head motion parameters and mean white matter (WM) and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) (with and without expansion terms), aCompCor, volume censoring (e.g., scrubbing and spike regression), global signal regression and ICA-AROMA, combined into 19 different pipelines. These pipelines were evaluated across five different quality control benchmarks in four independent datasets associated with varying levels of motion. Pipelines were benchmarked by examining the residual relationship between in-scanner movement and functional connectivity after denoising; the effect of distance on this residual relationship; whole-brain differences in functional connectivity between high- and low-motion healthy controls (HC); the temporal degrees of freedom lost during denoising; and the test-retest reliability of functional connectivity estimates. We also compared the sensitivity of each pipeline to clinical differences in functional connectivity in independent samples of people with schizophrenia and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Our results indicate that (1) simple linear regression of regional fMRI time series against head motion parameters and WM/CSF signals (with or without expansion terms) is not sufficient to remove head motion artefacts; (2) aCompCor pipelines may only be viable in low-motion data; (3) volume censoring performs well at minimising motion-related artefact but a major benefit of this approach derives from the exclusion of high-motion individuals; (4) while not as effective as volume censoring, ICA-AROMA performed well across our benchmarks for relatively low cost in terms of data loss; (5) the addition of global signal regression improved the performance of nearly all pipelines on most benchmarks, but exacerbated the distance-dependence of correlations between motion and functional connectivity; and (6) group comparisons in functional connectivity between healthy controls and schizophrenia patients are highly dependent on preprocessing strategy. We offer some recommendations for best practice and outline simple analyses to facilitate transparent reporting of the degree to which a given set of findings may be affected by motion-related artefact.

Methods to detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state fMRI

An evaluation of the efficacy, reliability, and sensitivity of motion correction strategies for resting-state functional MRI

Comparing different motion correction approaches for resting-state functional connectivity analysis with functional near-infrared spectroscopy data

Ridding fMRI data of motion-related influences: Removal of signals with distinct spatial and physical bases in multiecho data

Transient Arousal Modulations Contribute to Resting-State Functional Connectivity Changes Associated with Head Motion Parameters

Quantifying Residual Motion Artifacts in Fetal fMRI Data

Reduction of Motion Artifacts in Functional Connectivity Resulting from Infrequent Large Motion

Reproducibility and Sensitivity of Resting-State Fmri in Patients with Parkinson's Disease Using Cross Validation-Based Data Censoring

Agito ergo sum: correlates of spatiotemporal motion characteristics during fMRI

Motion Artifact Removal for Functional Near Infrared Spectroscopy: A Comparison of Methods

A Systematic Comparison of Motion Artifact Correction Techniques for Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy

Effects of Physiological Signal Removal on Resting-State Functional MRI Metrics

Advancing motion denoising of multiband resting-state functional connectivity fMRI data

The efficacy of resting-state fMRI denoising pipelines for motion correction and behavioural prediction.

Improved motion correction for functional MRI using an omnibus regression model

Strategies for motion- and respiration-robust estimation of fMRI intrinsic neural timescales

Effect of motion artifacts and their correction on near-infrared spectroscopy oscillation data: a study in healthy subjects and stroke patients

Data rescue in high-motion youth cohorts for robust and reproducible brain-behavior relationships

Attenuation of motion artifacts in fMRI using discrete reconstruction of irregular fMRI trajectories (DRIFT)

Inadequacy Of Motion Correction Algorithms In Functional Mri: Role Of Susceptibility-Induced Artifacts

Effective artifact removal in resting state fMRI data improves detection of DMN functional connectivity alteration in Alzheimer's disease