Abstract:The relevance of the topic is conditioned by the imperfection of norms on civil liability of guardians and custodians; the doctrine has not developed a coherent idea of contractual and tort liability of guardians and custodians. Judicial practice on disputes on contractual liability of guardians and trustees is contradictory. I. Civil liability of guardians of incapacitated citizens. According to the law, guardians are liable for the transactions of minors and are responsible for the harm caused by them. Judicial practice on contractual disputes concerning the recovery of utility payments for the use of residential premises by minor owners or tenants is contradictory. Courts either deny a claim against a guardian with reference to his/her lack of status as a family member; or claims against guardians are satisfied at the expense of the ward's property, but the guardians are not held liable in the form of penalties for late payment, as they did not enter into a contract with a resource supplying organisation on behalf of the owner. Similar rules are established by law for contractual and tort liability of guardians of adult mental patients who have been recognised as incapable. In disputes on contractual liability, the courts often rule that the debt should be recovered and the guardian should be held liable in the form of penalties. However, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation in one of the cases rejected the claim precisely because the guardian did not conclude a contract on behalf of the incapacitated person. II. Civil liability of guardians of citizens with incomplete legal capacity. The law defines the subjects of civil liability for the actions of minors aged 14 to 18 depending on the type of such liability: they bear contractual liability on their own; when they cause harm, the trustees are held jointly and severally liable. In the doctrine there is an opinion about shared tort liability of trustees, with which we cannot agree. Adult citizens, limited by the court in their legal capacity, bear independent contractual and tort liability. The doctrine criticises this rule with regard to tort liability. Thus, the Civil Code of the Russian Federation should provide for a mandatory condition common for guardians of any ward, i.e. the conclusion of a contract by them on behalf of the ward. If the contract was concluded prior to the appointment of a guardian or placement of the incapacitated person in organisations performing guardianship functions, the guardians may be liable for the execution of the contract, but only at the expense of the ward's property. The guardian is not liable under such a contract. It seems that the distinction in the legal regulation of the tort liability of guardians is unjustified for persons with limited legal capacity due to mental disorder - when they cause harm, guardians, as well as guardians of minors, should be held subsidiary liable. Subsidiary liability of trustees under the contracts of any wards should not arise.

Trust Management of Other People's Property: Reform on the Warpath

Perfecting the Separating Power System in Property Right Reform

Using the trust management mechanism as a way to prevent conflicts of interest in the public service: the US experience

Exploring Solutions to the Conflict between the Ownership of Trust Property and the Numerus Clauses

Real estate registers in Germany and Russia: Public credibility of data vs. bona fide acquisition of property

Development of Law Enforcement on Cases concerning Legal Regime of Marital Property in Contracts Involving Spouses

Reconstruction of China’s Farmland Rights System Based on the ‘trifurcation of Land Rights’ Reform

Current Issues in Reforming the Institution of Acquisitive Prescription in Russia, England, Hong Kong and Australia

Systematization of property claims in civil law

Оn the question of protection of property rights and determination of subjects of property use: analysis of judicial practice

Constancy of the property rights and the seizure of assets and corporate rights of russian companies: legal regulation in Ukraine and the experience of EU countries

Prospectives Of Trust Management Of Property In Uzbekistan

Facility under Construction and Investment in Property Maintenance and Improvement as part of the Joint Property of Spouses: Issues of Object Identification and Choice of Protection Method

Civil liability of guardians and trustees

INVIOLABILITY OF THE RIGHT OF OWNERSHIP OF SUBJECTS OF BUSINESS ACTIVITY

Construction and real estate: innovations of the legal regulation system

The Limits of Individual Regulation of Marital Relations based on a Marriage Contract

On Issue of a Management Company as a Participant in the Securities Market

Private International Law: Some Development Trends, Traditional and Novelization Institutions

The Legal Regime of Property of De Facto Spouses

Consistency of Law Enforcement Practice in Matters of Deviation from the Principle of Equality of the Spouses’ Shares in Their Common Property