Abstract:Abstract Models of trait evolution form an important part of macroevolutionary biology. The Brownian motion model and Ornstein–Uhlenbeck models have become classic (null) models of character evolution, in which species evolve independently. Recently, models incorporating species interactions have been developed, particularly involving competition where abiotic factors pull species toward an optimal trait value and competitive interactions drive the trait values apart. However, these models assume a fitness function rather than derive it from population dynamics and they do not consider dynamics of the trait variance. Here, we develop a general coherent trait evolution framework where the fitness function is based on a model of population dynamics, and therefore it can, in principle, accommodate any type of species interaction. We illustrate our framework with a model of abundance-dependent competitive interactions against a macroevolutionary background encoded in a phylogenetic tree. We develop an inference tool based on Approximate Bayesian Computation and test it on simulated data (of traits at the tips). We find that inference performs well when the diversity predicted by the parameters equals the number of species in the phylogeny. We then fit the model to empirical data of baleen whale body lengths, using three different summary statistics, and compare it to a model without population dynamics and a model where competition depends on the total metabolic rate of the competitors. We show that the unweighted model performs best for the least informative summary statistic, while the model with competition weighted by the total metabolic rate fits the data slightly better than the other two models for the two more informative summary statistics. Regardless of the summary statistic used, the three models substantially differ in their predictions of the abundance distribution. Therefore, data on abundance distributions will allow us to better distinguish the models from one another, and infer the nature of species interactions. Thus, our framework provides a conceptual approach to reveal species interactions underlying trait evolution and identifies the data needed to do so in practice. [Approximate Bayesian computation; competition; phylogeny; population dynamics; simulations; species interaction; trait evolution.]

Limitations of inclusive fitness

The Strategic Reference Gene: an organismal theory of inclusive fitness

The inclusive fitness controversy: finding a way forward

Extensive fitness and human cooperation

Extended Inclusive Fitness Theory bridges Economics and Biology through a common understanding of Social Synergy

The general form of Hamilton’s rule makes no predictions and cannot be tested empirically

Levels of selection and macroevolution in organisms, colonies, and species

Natural selection. I. Variable environments and uncertain returns on investment

Fitness as the organismal performance measure guiding adaptive evolution

How does the mode of evolutionary divergence affect reproductive isolation?

Epistasis and the structure of fitness landscapes: are experimental fitness landscapes compatible with Fisher's Geometric model?

Inferring the Effect of Species Interactions on Trait Evolution

Interpretations Arising From Wrightian And Malthusian Fitness Under Strong Frequency Dependent Selection

Evolutionary Fitness in Variable Environments

A mathematical analysis of the evolutionary benefits of sexual reproduction

Percolation on fitness landscapes: Effects of correlation, phenotype, and incompatibilities

A gene-based model of fitness and its implications for genetic variation

Using Fourier Transform to Connect Phenotype and Fitness of Complex Traits

An Evolutionary Theory for the Variability Hypothesis

A comprehensive representation of selection at loci with multiple alleles that allows complex forms of genotypic fitness

Beyond fitness: The information imparted in population states by selection throughout lifecycles