Quantitative Analysis and Visualized Evidence for High Charge Separation Efficiency in a SolidLiquid Bulk Heterojunction
Xin Zhao,Wenjun Luo,Mingxue Li,Zhaosheng Li,Zhigang Zou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/aenm.201301785
IF: 27.8
2014-01-01
Advanced Energy Materials
Abstract:DOI: 10.1002/aenm.201301785 photovoltaic (PV) cell (using, for example, silicon or gallium arsenide), though capable of achieving a high conversion effi ciency, faces the main obstacle of high cost for largescale application because of the requirement of high purity and low defect density. In the past few decades, some novel cells of low cost have been explored to convert solar energy into electrical or chemical energy, such as organic photovoltaic cells (OPV), photoelectrochemical solar cells, and photoelectrochemical solar water splitting cells. [ 1–5 ] In these devices, a key limit in a planar structure cell for high effi ciency is the incompatibility between a short diffusion length of minority carriers and a long optical absorption length. To overcome the limit, bulk heterojunction (BHJ) concept is fi rst introduced in an OPV cell, [ 6 ] which consists of an interpenetrating network of donor and acceptor materials. [ 7,8 ] The performance of the BHJ solar cell depends on the morphology very sensitively. A large interface area is usually necessary for high separation effi ciency. In a photoelectrochemical solar cell or water splitting cell, one-dimensional nanostructure (nanowires, nanorods, or nanotubes), [ 9–12 ] branched nanostructure, [ 13,14 ] and porous structures, [ 15–19 ] are used to increase light capture and decrease diffusion distance of minority carriers to the interface. In a nanostructured photoelectrochemical cell, electrolyte can penetrate into the bulk of a solid photoelectrode. Therefore, analogically, a nanostructured photoelectrochemical cell can be considered as a solid-electrolyte bulk heterojunction. Generally, higher light absorption and/or charge separation effi ciency are considered as the main reasons for improved performance in a nanostructured cell than a planar structure. However, quantitative analysis and defi nite experimental evidence remain elusive. It is diffi cult to directly compare a nanostructured cell with a planar cell because the controlled samples are usually prepared by different methods or different conditions. Especially, in an OPV, it is diffi cult to investigate the details once the cell is assembled and a solid-solid interface forms. Therefore, it is impossible to identify quantitative contribution of each factor. Only some qualitative conclusions are given in previous studies. In the past few decades, some novel low-cost nanostructured devices have been explored for converting solar energy into electrical or chemical energy, such as organic photovoltaic cells, photoelectrochemical solar cells, and solar water splitting cells. Generally, higher light absorption and/or charge separation effi ciency are considered as the main reasons for improved performance in a nanostructured device versus a planar structure. However, quantitative analysis and defi nite experimental evidence remain elusive. Here, using BiVO 4 as an example, comparable samples with porous and dense structures have been prepared by a simple method. The porous and dense fi lms are assembled into a solid-electrolyte bulk and planar heterojunction, respectively. Some quantitative results are obtained by decoupling photon absorption, interfacial charge transfer, and charge separation processes. These results suggest that higher charge separation effi ciency is mainly responsible for enhanced performance in a solid-electrolyte bulk heterojunction. Moreover, we also present visualized evidence to show higher charge separation effi ciency comes from a shorter photo-generated hole diffusion distance in a bulk heterojunction. These results can deepen understanding charge transfer in a bulk heterojunction and offer guidance to design a more effi cient lowcost device for solar conversion and storage.