Re-Reading the Romance: Genre and Gender in Isabel Allende's 'Niña Perversa'

Claire Lindsay
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/ros.2001.19.2.135
2001-12-01
Romance Studies
Abstract:Much of the current criticism of the work of the Chilean author Isabel Allende hinges on the premise that she exploits the romance genre in her best selling novels such as La casa de los espíritus (1982) and Eva Luna (1988). Critics haue also drawn attention to this factor in her 1990 collection of short stories, Cuentos de Eva Luna. However, as I shall argue in this article, detailed reading reveals that there is much more to the fiction of this author than simply conventional, sentimental romance. Taking issue with critical assertions which neatly tend to classify Allende's work, I will first undertake a general discussion of romance, drawing upon the current debate in cultural studies surrounding the genre, particularly amongst feminist scholars. Furthermore, using socio-psychoanalytic theory, I will then offer a reading of 'Niña perversa' which reveals that Allende uses the romance in her story not in order to endorse conventions, but rather in order to address and contest regressive patriarchal ideas.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?