Research on Consumer Responses to Unsatisfactory Service
Wang Lili,Lü Wei,Huang Jing,Jiang Lin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2009.04.004
2009-01-01
Abstract:Previous research on consumer dissatisfaction mainly focused on service failure and consumer complaints. In order to clearly explain consumer complaints, quantitative research has paid attention to complaint types, the determinants of complaints and the impact of the complaint on subsequent behavior. Meanwhile, prior studies supply numerous models, such as those concerning consumer complaint behavior, consumer responses, and consumer complaint responses. However, other types of dissatisfaction responses which coexist with complaints were neglected in previous marketing research. This gap is filled with the present research. In this paper, the authors use the EVLN model as a reference, which features a well-known employee response model in the context of organizations and incorporates the exit, voice, loyalty and neglect kinds of response. The authors also refer to the result of channel management research. Based on exploratory factor analysis and confirmed factor analysis, the paper empirically tests the proposed model. The authors also test the reliability and validity of the scales. In this model, there were five kinds of response: exit, creative suggestion, passive acceptance, venting and legal action. Through structural estimation model analysis, we can divide these five kinds into two categories: negative and positive responses. Furthermore, we use the magnitude of dissatisfaction to empirically test the difference between these five responses. We find that the more dissatisfied consumers were, the more likely they were to make negative responses. We also explore the hypothesis that males and females have different attitudes towards legal action and creative suggestions. Females were more inclined to use legal action while males were more likely to give creative suggestions. Meanwhile, consumers with different education levels had a clear preference for legal action and exit. Students in college and university were more likely to take extreme behavior such as exit and legal action. To conclude, we point out the limitations of this research and propose a future research direction. We also provide some management and marketing implications.